←back to thread

192 points beedeebeedee | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
lysace ◴[] No.41907169[source]
I find it weird that China has a very tight information control and simultaneously over and over again has the weirdest "netizen" rumors that go mainstream.

What's the explanation? That they are explicitly allowed for some strategical reason? Something else?

Edit: @dang: Sorry in advance. I do feel like we got some pretty good discussion around this explosive topic, at least in its first hour.

Folks, keep up the good behavior — it makes me look good.

replies(13): >>41907221 #>>41907399 #>>41907480 #>>41907484 #>>41907535 #>>41907573 #>>41907660 #>>41907690 #>>41907710 #>>41907794 #>>41907883 #>>41907954 #>>41909239 #
erulabs ◴[] No.41907399[source]
My explanation is that their tight control is an illusion. Not to get political, but the illusion of power is power, and suggesting they control billions of peoples speech is certainly an illusion of power.

China, and all other (supposedly) top-down-economies, survive only because their control is not airtight. If they were to actually have complete control, things would fall apart rapidly. “No one knows how Paris is fed” and all that.

replies(6): >>41907440 #>>41907493 #>>41907550 #>>41907671 #>>41907737 #>>41908047 #
lysace ◴[] No.41907493[source]
From my work visits and sort of guarded discussions with people there: I feel like they have just accepted the inevitable. Don't ask weird questions about things you're not supposed to ask about, be pragmatic, get things gone, get rich.
replies(1): >>41907576 #
erulabs ◴[] No.41907576[source]
My experience as well! Pragmatism over idealism is a fantastic virtue for everyone — but turns out a vital one for communists :P
replies(4): >>41907897 #>>41907901 #>>41908138 #>>41908695 #
throwaway19972 ◴[] No.41907901[source]
Is there any culture on earth that prioritizes idealism over "pragmatism", if we must use that term? What does this even look like?
replies(2): >>41907974 #>>41908256 #
1. erulabs ◴[] No.41908256{3}[source]
I mean, one could argue that the early Soviet Union suffered from this issue. Or early revolutionary China. Cambodia is certainly an example. The french revolution might be an even better example, what with wanting to re-do the clock and calendar and such. To convert startup culture speak's "pragmatism beats idealism" into political science speak, it might come out as "rationalism has tremendous difficultly reinventing all unconscious behavior".