←back to thread

181 points andrewstetsenko | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0.475s | source
Show context
bloated5048 ◴[] No.41895801[source]
Does it mean exercising regularly does the same?
replies(2): >>41895819 #>>41895863 #
mattmaroon ◴[] No.41895819[source]
Exercise seems to stimulate the mechanisms it’s claiming stress depresses, so probably no.
replies(1): >>41895861 #
bloated5048 ◴[] No.41895861[source]
But exercise does use lots of energy. Probably more than stress.
replies(4): >>41895971 #>>41896069 #>>41896740 #>>41897511 #
1. mattmaroon ◴[] No.41896069[source]
I don’t think the claim is that it just uses energy, it’s that it uses energy to the detriment of other processes.

The body is extraordinarily complex, so I don’t think you can extrapolate that to anything else that uses energy.

Any garden variety gym rat will tell you that when you worked out you eat a lot more. And that may be the same for stress, but perhaps what your body does with the energy when you exercise is different.

replies(1): >>41897600 #
2. anon84873628 ◴[] No.41897600[source]
Exercise modulates hunger (generally, cardio increases perceived hunger while resistance training actually blunts it for a time). But people putting in work at the gym are already in a health conscious mindset and will apply that to their food choices, even if they aren't on an explicit diet plan. If you just left a gallon of sweat on the treadmill you're probably not gonna buy a pizza or McDonald's burger in the way home. It just feels like an obvious step backwards in the moment.

Meanwhile, being in a stressed state that reduces executive function is going to lead people to the quick, easy, hyper palatable, high energy density, unhealthy food options available.