←back to thread

238 points ferbivore | 6 comments | | HN request time: 0.893s | source | bottom
Show context
andag ◴[] No.41894416[source]
Going proprietary is one thing, but doing it in several steps in different repos and saying nothing about it I really don't like...

What are open alternatives at this point?

replies(2): >>41894525 #>>41895554 #
1. ferbivore ◴[] No.41894525[source]
The KeePass ecosystem has gotten a little bit better. It's still not exactly seamless. File sync across all of Windows, Linux, macOS, iOS and Android seems to involve either proprietary user-hostile sync tools or dealing with lots of jank.

As far as I can tell, the only competitor with a similar feature set that even claims to be open-source is Proton Pass. But I can't find any information on whether the server side can be self-hosted.

replies(2): >>41894633 #>>41895372 #
2. selfhoster11 ◴[] No.41894633[source]
KeePass as an ecosystem (and possibly other file-based ecosystems) is something I’ve used for around a decade, and while it’s not perfect, I am 100% sure it will be there for me in another decade. I want to own my passwords, and KeePass feels like a safe pair of hands that won’t turn hostile when I’m not looking.

IMO, the secret to keeping the passwords synced with KeePass, is to make sure your client has a direct feature to sync the passwords database to a remote server - SFTP, DAV, SMB, etc. Then all you need to do is to set up a single remote file share to serve that file. Or sync manually, assuming your passwords change slowly - KeePass 2 can sync changes automatically between KDBX files.

3. jasonjayr ◴[] No.41895372[source]
Windows, Linux, Android are pretty easily + reliably covered by SyncThing.

What's the best story for iOS or MacOS?

replies(3): >>41896200 #>>41896279 #>>41901900 #
4. luoc ◴[] No.41896200[source]
Meanwhile: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41895718

While there seems to be an alternative, the root cause of Google's hostility to foss apps does not make me optimistic about this being a stable solution in the long run :(

5. terminalbraid ◴[] No.41896279[source]
Android is not anymore

https://forum.syncthing.net/t/discontinuing-syncthing-androi...

6. ssbash ◴[] No.41901900[source]
Strongbox - I’ve been using it for the past two years. It’s been rock solid and has gotten a few useful updates in that time.

here’s an older of comment of mine for more details: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36022210