←back to thread

549 points orcul | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.205s | source
Show context
Animats ◴[] No.41890003[source]
This is an important result.

The actual paper [1] says that functional MRI (which is measuring which parts of the brain are active by sensing blood flow) indicates that different brain hardware is used for non-language and language functions. This has been suspected for years, but now there's an experimental result.

What this tells us for AI is that we need something else besides LLMs. It's not clear what that something else is. But, as the paper mentions, the low-end mammals and the corvids lack language but have some substantial problem-solving capability. That's seen down at squirrel and crow size, where the brains are tiny. So if someone figures out to do this, it will probably take less hardware than an LLM.

This is the next big piece we need for AI. No idea how to do this, but it's the right question to work on.

[1] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-024-07522-w.epdf?shar...

replies(35): >>41890104 #>>41890470 #>>41891063 #>>41891228 #>>41891262 #>>41891383 #>>41891507 #>>41891639 #>>41891749 #>>41892068 #>>41892137 #>>41892518 #>>41892576 #>>41892603 #>>41892642 #>>41892738 #>>41893400 #>>41893534 #>>41893555 #>>41893732 #>>41893748 #>>41893960 #>>41894031 #>>41894713 #>>41895796 #>>41895908 #>>41896452 #>>41896476 #>>41896479 #>>41896512 #>>41897059 #>>41897270 #>>41897757 #>>41897835 #>>41905326 #
1. NeuroCoder ◴[] No.41891639[source]
I'm not convinced the result is as important here as the methods. Separating language from complex cognition when evaluating individuals is difficult. But many of the people I've met in neuroscience that study language and cognitive processes do not hold the opinion that one is absolutely reliant on the other in all cases. It may have been a strong argument a while ago, but everytime I've seen a presentation on this relationship it's been to emphasize the influence culture and language inevitably have on how we think about things. I'm sure some people believe that one cannot have complex thoughts without language, but most people in speech neuro I've met in language processing research find the idea ridiculous enough they wouldn't bother spending a few years on that kind of project just to disapprove a theory.

On the other hand, further understanding how to engage complex cognitive processes in nonverbal individuals is extremely useful and difficult to accomplish.