←back to thread

321 points jhunter1016 | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.193s | source
Show context
twoodfin ◴[] No.41878632[source]
Stay for the end and the hilarious idea that OpenAI’s board could declare one day that they’ve created AGI simply to weasel out of their contract with Microsoft.
replies(4): >>41878980 #>>41878982 #>>41880653 #>>41880775 #
fragmede ◴[] No.41880653[source]
The question is how rigorously defined is AGI in their contract? Given how much AGI is a nebulous concept of smartness and reasoning ability and thinking, how are they going to declare when it has or hasn't been achieved. What stops Microsoft from weaseling out of the contract by saying they never reach it.
replies(2): >>41880701 #>>41880868 #
JacobThreeThree ◴[] No.41880868[source]
OpenAI's short definition of AGI is:

A highly autonomous system that outperform humans at most economically valuable work.

replies(4): >>41881028 #>>41881206 #>>41881215 #>>41882567 #
1. aithrowawaycomm ◴[] No.41882567[source]
I think I saw the following insight on Arvind Narayanan's Twitter, don't have a specific cite:

The biggest problem with this definition is that work ceases to be economically valuable once a machine is able to do it, while human capacity will expand to do new work that wouldn't be possible without the machines. In developed countries machines are doing most of the economically valuable work once done by medieval peasants, without any relation to AGI whatsoever. Many 1950s accounting and secretarial tasks could be done by a cheap computer in the 1990s. So what exactly is the cutoff point here for "economically valuable work"?

The second biggest problem is that "most" is awfully slippery, and seems designed to prematurely declare victory via mathiness. If by some accounting a simple majority of tasks for a given role can be done with no real cognition beyond rote memorization, with the remaining cognitively-demanding tasks being shunted into "manager" or "prompt engineer" roles, then they can unfurl the Mission Accomplished banner and say they automated that role.