←back to thread

201 points andsoitis | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.209s | source
Show context
defrost ◴[] No.41854450[source]
For an interesting side piece:

    Curiously, however, for a system apparently stultified by the dead hand of government, Australia’s health system far outperforms the free market-based US healthcare system, which spends nearly twice as much per capita as Australia to deliver far worse outcomes — including Americans dying five years younger than us.
The shocking truth: Australia has a world-leading health system — because of governments

Source: https://www.crikey.com.au/2024/10/16/pubic-private-healthcar...

Bypass: https://clearthis.page/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.crikey.com.au%2F...

    Overall, we now have the fourth-highest life expectancy in the world.

   This is contrary to the narrative that pervades the media about our health system — one in which our “frontline” health workers heroically battle to overcome government neglect and inadequate spending, while the population is beset by various “epidemics” — obesity, alcohol, illicit drugs.

    In fact, Australian longevity is so remarkable that in August The Economist published a piece simply titled “Why do Australians live so long?”
Other references:

The Economist: https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2024/08/23/why-do-a...

AU Gov Report: Advances in measuring healthcare productivity https://www.pc.gov.au/research/completed/measuring-healthcar...

replies(14): >>41854605 #>>41854613 #>>41854799 #>>41855053 #>>41855120 #>>41855218 #>>41855732 #>>41856242 #>>41856326 #>>41857738 #>>41857930 #>>41857960 #>>41858153 #>>41876405 #
alwayslikethis ◴[] No.41854605[source]
> the free market-based US healthcare system

market, maybe, "free" market? I doubt it.

It's not a very free market when there is such a large power differential between the buyer and the seller. You can't exactly shop around for the ambulance or the hospital when you need it, nor can you realistically circumvent the artificially constrained supply [1] of doctors to get cheaper healthcare (unless you live next to the border).

When the alternative is a one-sided market like this, government becomes rather more appealing.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Medical_Association#R...

replies(7): >>41856252 #>>41856671 #>>41856804 #>>41857003 #>>41857443 #>>41858041 #>>41859036 #
WalterBright ◴[] No.41856252[source]
> You can't exactly shop around

The vast bulk of health care is by appointment, not a dash in the ambulance.

replies(4): >>41856343 #>>41856368 #>>41856730 #>>41860972 #
yellottyellott ◴[] No.41860972[source]
other than normal doctor’s office visits, i have no idea what i’m going to pay when i get a small procedure done.

a basic heart ultrasound cost me over $1k while my vasectomy cost me a $60 copay. i was expecting those prices to be flipped.

and don’t get me started on labs. i’ve gotten bills for basic screens years later for thousands of dollars.

you can’t shop around if you don’t know what you’ll pay until months after it happens. if you call the insurance company beforehand you wait on a static filled line with a call center in india, and even with the CPT code they can’t give you a straight answer.

replies(1): >>41862082 #
WalterBright ◴[] No.41862082[source]
> i have no idea what i’m going to pay when i get a small procedure done.

All you gotta do is ask.

replies(3): >>41862469 #>>41862973 #>>41878799 #
1. yellottyellott ◴[] No.41878799[source]
if you ask the provider you will eventually get burned. they can only give you the cash price as a backstop.

if you ask the insurance company you’ll never get an answer. providers are usually more helpful about what “should be covered”, but that’s not guaranteed.

seems like prior authorization is the only way to really make sure charges are covered but takes forever. but even then, if your insurance covers $x and they bill $y, you might get a balance bill in the mail.

point is, the market is heavily skewed against the consumer.