←back to thread

Inkscape 1.4 Released

(inkscape.org)
280 points s1291 | 3 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
tetris11 ◴[] No.41873413[source]
The more I learn about the SVG spec, the more I understand the rationale of some of the UI decisions inkscape made, and the more impressed I am by how they implemented advanced techniques like shape union and intersection, clipping and masking.
replies(2): >>41874382 #>>41874729 #
AlienRobot ◴[] No.41874729[source]
From the little I know about SVG, I wish there was an open source alternative to Inkscape that didn't support standard SVG but used a proprietary format instead.

Almost everything you need to create vector art, SVG doesn't support.

Multiple outlines in a single shape? No. Varying thickness in an outline? No. Rounded corners on arbitrary vertices? No. Non-destructive boolean operations? No. I'm not even sure SVG supports paragraphs.

Many of these Inkscape implements as live filters, which are saved as SVG extensions in the XML .svg file that nobody but Inkscape can properly load.

SVG is ridiculously bad as a creation format. It's a good format to export to, but as a backend and it's just insane. It's like using a single PNG file as a backend for your multi-layer 128bpp raster project.

I use Inkscape a lot but I can't help but notice that the best vector art illustration come from Affinity Designer, Corel Draw, and Adobe Illustrator. If you compare the quality of artwork made with proprietary tools to those made with Inkscape, it's very clear that Inkscape severely limits what artists can achieve. You can easily create complex illustrations in other tools that would be a nightmare to manage in Inkscape. Just compare how you clip something in Inkscape to how you do it in Affinity. It's ridiculous how different the two workflows are.

replies(8): >>41874996 #>>41875026 #>>41875131 #>>41875637 #>>41875872 #>>41875900 #>>41875916 #>>41876228 #
1. sourcepluck ◴[] No.41875872[source]
I'm very ignorant in these areas, but if you don't mind me asking - how would using a proprietary format solve issues for Inkscape, or an imagined alternative to Inkscape?

Do all the others (AD, CD, AI) use some proprietary format that makes their life easier? Is there no better alternative to SVG on the open source side of things?

replies(2): >>41875884 #>>41876217 #
2. insane_dreamer ◴[] No.41875884[source]
Illustrator uses its own proprietary .ai format (which Inkscape can load IIRC)
3. Gigachad ◴[] No.41876217[source]
A proprietary format would allow doing anything, without having to worry about how other programs will support it.

There’s a conflict between what is needed to simply display images, and what is needed for an ideal editable document.

A web browser doesn’t need the complexity of non destructive Boolean operations, but an editor program does. It can all be exported to SVG at the end once it doesn’t need to be edited anymore. Things like variable thickness outlines can just be turned in to filled Bézier curve shapes that happen to be the shape of the outline.