←back to thread

Use Prolog to improve LLM's reasoning

(shchegrikovich.substack.com)
232 points shchegrikovich | 10 comments | | HN request time: 0.204s | source | bottom
1. pjmlp ◴[] No.41872982[source]
So we are back to Japanese Fifth Generation plan from 1980's. :)
replies(5): >>41873176 #>>41873178 #>>41873253 #>>41873890 #>>41874052 #
2. thelastparadise ◴[] No.41873176[source]
Watson did it too, a while back.
3. tokinonagare ◴[] No.41873178[source]
Missing some LISP but yeah it's funny how old things are new again (same story with wasm, RISC archs, etc.)
replies(1): >>41873328 #
4. linguae ◴[] No.41873253[source]
This time around we have all sorts of parallel processing capabilities in the form of GPUs. If I recall correctly, the Fifth Generation project envisioned highly parallel machines performing symbolic AI. From a hardware standpoint, those researchers were way ahead of their time.
replies(1): >>41873372 #
5. nxobject ◴[] No.41873328[source]
Lots of GOFAI being implemented again – decision trees, goal searching and planning, agent-based strategies... just not symbolic representations, and that might be the key. I figure you might get an interesting contribution out of skimming old AI laboratory publications and seeing whether you could find a way of implementing it through a single LLM, multiple LLM agents, methods of training, etc.
replies(2): >>41873922 #>>41874791 #
6. nxobject ◴[] No.41873372[source]
And they had a self-sustaining video game industry too... if only someone had had the wild thought of implementing perceptrons and tensor arithmetic on the same hardware!
7. postepowanieadm ◴[] No.41873890[source]
and winter is coming.
8. anthk ◴[] No.41873922{3}[source]
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constraint_satisfaction_prob...
9. metadat ◴[] No.41874052[source]
For the uninitiated (like me):

The Japanese Fifth Generation Project

https://www.sjsu.edu/faculty/watkins/5thgen.htm

10. nmadden ◴[] No.41874791{3}[source]
Indeed, modern ML has been a validation of (some of) GOFAI: https://neilmadden.blog/2024/06/30/machine-learning-and-the-...