←back to thread

Reflections on Palantir

(nabeelqu.substack.com)
479 points freditup | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.001s | source
Show context
austinjp ◴[] No.41867353[source]
The article reveals depressing reasons why someone might choose to work for the lines of Palantir: lots of talented people working on hard problems. That's pretty much it. No problem with the business model, just intellectual hunger. I'm sure the pay didn't hurt.

We need to teach our students that the employment they take doesn't exist in a vacuum. Your choice of employee can impact not only yourself but the wider world. There's more to life than intellectual satisfaction.

replies(13): >>41867539 #>>41868032 #>>41868044 #>>41868131 #>>41868249 #>>41868281 #>>41869268 #>>41869297 #>>41869514 #>>41869654 #>>41869665 #>>41869723 #>>41869727 #
clircle ◴[] No.41868249[source]
> We need to teach our students...

Teach your values to your own kids, man

replies(4): >>41868777 #>>41868824 #>>41868931 #>>41869167 #
cambaceres ◴[] No.41868777[source]
The perfect response to this kind of preaching.
replies(3): >>41868954 #>>41868988 #>>41869449 #
moolcool ◴[] No.41868954[source]
I don't think it's preachy at all to say "Hey, the work you do has impacts on the wider world"
replies(2): >>41869002 #>>41869008 #
next_xibalba[dead post] ◴[] No.41869008[source]
[flagged]
1. soulofmischief ◴[] No.41869534[source]
This comment is a great example of a straw man argument.

> leave moral instruction to parents and other institutions like it should be.

Should be, according to what doctrine? It certainly sounds like you're attempting to establish institutional moral instruction by imposing limits on when and where morality can be discussed.

Why are we allowed to teach students astronomy but not morality? Go back further and we couldn't even freely teach astronomy. Do you remember Galileo's trial for heresy? Or Socrates' condemnation to death for "corrupting the youth"? This war for teaching the ability to capably assess ethics and morality has been waging before you, I, Hacker News, universities, the internet, the printing press...

If you don't think it was right to kill Socrates for simply spreading the message of critical thinking, then you have to accept that adults can organize to teach whatever they wish at universities, assuming it doesn't run afoul of Constitutional protections.