←back to thread

238 points chmaynard | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0.407s | source
Show context
CodeWriter23 ◴[] No.41866710[source]
@WPEngine - fork Wordpress, rebrand yourself and the code. Setup a plugin / update hub like Wordpress.org and provide a pathway for your customers and devs to migrate. I recognize this is non-trivial. Ending an abusive relationship usually is.
replies(1): >>41866835 #
spiderfarmer ◴[] No.41866835[source]
They profit off Wordpress' brand for free. Maintaining a fork and building a new brand will be expensive. As much as I despise Matt's antics, there's not much to gain for WPEngine by forking it.

The best scenario for all parties is to burry the hatch and for Matt to step down.

replies(3): >>41866902 #>>41867053 #>>41871143 #
kergonath ◴[] No.41866902[source]
> They profit off Wordpress' brand for free.

What the hell are you on about? Wordpress is GPL. Are all Linux distro profiting off Linus’ brand?

There is a very simple thing you can do if you don’t want people to do this: use a different license. You cannot eat your cake and keep having it.

> Maintaining a fork and building a new brand will be expensive.

Publishing free software is a decision. You cannot come years later to say “no, actually you need to pay”, or “yeah, it’s free but not like that”.

The whole “WPE does not contribute” point is completely disingenuous and I cannot believe that people are still uttering it in good faith.

> The best scenario for all parties is to burry the hatch and for Matt to step down.

The best scenario is Wordpress going up in flames, Matt being utterly ridiculed for his dishonest behaviour and the whole thing serving as a cautionary tale.

replies(4): >>41866997 #>>41867212 #>>41868945 #>>41871657 #
spiderfarmer ◴[] No.41868945[source]
> Are all Linux distro profiting off Linus’ brand?

Those aren't forks. Full forking the Linux kernel and rebranding it would be hard for the same reasons as forking and rebranding Wordpress.

> Publishing free software is a decision. You cannot come years later to say “no, actually you need to pay”, or “yeah, it’s free but not like that”.

That's not my point. My point is: if they want to fork it, it will be expensive.

> The best scenario is Wordpress going up in flames, Matt being utterly ridiculed for his dishonest behaviour and the whole thing serving as a cautionary tale.

Why would that be better?

replies(3): >>41869499 #>>41870554 #>>41873384 #
1. e40 ◴[] No.41869499[source]
This is precisely what Red Hat did, right?
replies(1): >>41870301 #
2. spiderfarmer ◴[] No.41870301[source]
Red Hat still includes the Linux kernel. Android would be a better example of an actual fork.