←back to thread

230 points mdp2021 | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.201s | source
Show context
Crazyontap ◴[] No.41866060[source]
When I was younger, I was fascinated by evolution, especially the intricacies of how things just work. This fascination also explains why many people believe in the intelligent design theory.

However, witnessing the rapid evolution of AI with just a few hundred GPUs, enough data, and power, I no longer wonder what a billion years of feedback loops and randomness can achieve.

replies(18): >>41866202 #>>41866478 #>>41866660 #>>41866806 #>>41866826 #>>41867595 #>>41867652 #>>41867789 #>>41867813 #>>41867833 #>>41867834 #>>41867913 #>>41868264 #>>41868344 #>>41868565 #>>41868579 #>>41869785 #>>41909242 #
nkrisc ◴[] No.41867834[source]
The fascination with “intelligent design” is cherry-picking. The is no shortage of “unintelligent design” in the natural world.

Take humans, for example. You can block your trachea and die through the simple act of eating. An intelligent (and omniscient) designer could have avoided that by better designing our overall our overall structure.

Or take the fact or ear bones are modified jaw bones. Or if you believe in intelligent design, ask why our intelligent designer thought it wise to link our jaw to our ears so that it’s hard to hear things when you’re chewing.

replies(6): >>41868255 #>>41868278 #>>41868279 #>>41869004 #>>41870013 #>>41870608 #
smusamashah ◴[] No.41868279[source]
When you notice these flaws you are seeing it in very very short term. What we are today is what eventually worked for a million years. The design you see today is the way it is because it had to be robust enough (including those problems) to survive to this day.

The examples you quote do look like a problem today, but I think they must have worked to some benefit to bring us here.

replies(6): >>41868301 #>>41868308 #>>41868460 #>>41868711 #>>41868965 #>>41871167 #
1. rakoo ◴[] No.41868965[source]
> I think they must have worked to some benefit to bring us here.

No, the other consequence of evolution is that whatever we are today is not enough to kill us. Some of the things in our bodies and behavior are just useless, but not bad enough that they endanger our life and cut the genetic deviation responsible for it, so it just keeps on being there.

There's no good reason we still have 5 fingers on feet, but they're also not bad enough that having them all would endanger us as as species, so they just stay there.