←back to thread

The Stallman Report

(stallman-report.org)
197 points pkilgore | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
o999 ◴[] No.41847507[source]
Puberty was considered the adulthood age for mellinia, that is suitable for marriage (and is still considered so in several places).

Why is this a very controversial topic?

replies(4): >>41847724 #>>41857151 #>>41872691 #>>41892762 #
shadowgovt ◴[] No.41847724[source]
Taboos are often controversial.

And if he were a sociologist or anthropologist, published in the field with any reputation at all in it, who could speak on that complex dynamic over history and the interplay between environment, tradition, human biology, and social context, he might have a prayer of using reason to move the needle on the taboos in his own culture. But he's not. He's a professor in another field speaking way out on the deep end of a field he doesn't have the credentials to be taken seriously in.

We all have freedom of speech, but academic professors are expected to uphold a level of rigor that most people are not, and his writings on this topic harm his credibility and therefore, indirectly, his ability to advocate for free software.

replies(1): >>41848998 #
fsflover ◴[] No.41848998[source]
But does he have a right for his personal opinion in a free country?
replies(2): >>41849594 #>>41867938 #
1. ◴[] No.41867938[source]