←back to thread

486 points dbreunig | 9 comments | | HN request time: 0.442s | source | bottom
1. jamesy0ung ◴[] No.41863532[source]
What exactly does Windows do with a NPU? I don't own an 'AI PC' but it seems like the NPUs are slow and can't run much.

I know Apple's Neural Engine is used to power Face ID and the facial recognition stuff in Photos, among other things.

replies(3): >>41863977 #>>41864404 #>>41864731 #
2. DrillShopper ◴[] No.41863977[source]
It supports Microsoft's Recall (now required) spyware
replies(1): >>41864269 #
3. Janicc ◴[] No.41864269[source]
Please remind me again how Recall sends data to Microsoft. I must've missed that part. Or are you against the print screen button too? I heard that takes images too. Very scary.
replies(4): >>41864321 #>>41864416 #>>41864507 #>>41864559 #
4. dagaci ◴[] No.41864404[source]
Its used for improving video calls, special effects, image editing/ effects and noise cancelling, teams stuff
5. cmeacham98 ◴[] No.41864416{3}[source]
While calling it spyware like GP is over-exaggeration to a ridiculous level, comparing Recall to Print Screen is also inaccurate:

Print Screen takes images on demand, Recall does so effectively at random. This means Recall could inadvertently screenshot and store information you didn't intend to keep a record of (To give an extreme example: Imagine an abuser uses Recall to discover their spouse browsing online domestic violence resources).

6. Terr_ ◴[] No.41864507{3}[source]
> Please remind me again how Recall sends data to Microsoft. I must've missed that part.

Sure, just post the source code and I'll point out where it does so, I somehow misplaced my copy. /s

The core problem here is trust, and over the last several years Microsoft has burned a hell of a lot of theirs with power-users of Windows. Even their most strident public promises of Recall being "opt-in" and "on-device only" will--paradoxically--only be kept as long as enough people remain suspicious.

Glance away and MS go back to their old games, pushing a mandatory "security update" which reset or entirely-removes your privacy settings and adding new "telemetry" streams which you cannot inspect.

7. bloated5048 ◴[] No.41864559{3}[source]
It's always safe to assume it does if it's closed source. I rather be suspicious of big corporations seeking to profit at every step than naive.

Also, it's security risk which already been exploited. Sure, MS fixed it, but can you be certain it won't be exploited some time in the future again?

8. downrightmike ◴[] No.41864731[source]
AI PC is just a marketing term, doesn't have any real substance
replies(1): >>41865216 #
9. acdha ◴[] No.41865216[source]
Yea, we know that. I believe that’s why the person you’re replying too was asking for examples of real usage.