←back to thread

Reflections on Palantir

(nabeelqu.substack.com)
479 points freditup | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
giraffe_lady[dead post] ◴[] No.41861626[source]
[flagged]
Manuel_D[dead post] ◴[] No.41861677[source]
[flagged]
torlok ◴[] No.41861850[source]
How can you type something like this after the numerous independent reports of IDF behaviour, civilian casualties in Gaza, and the treatment of Palestinians in the West Bank? I can't believe anybody can just ignore reality like that.
replies(1): >>41861957 #
Manuel_D ◴[] No.41861957[source]
Can you define the term "genocide"?
replies(2): >>41862034 #>>41862126 #
tsimionescu ◴[] No.41862034[source]
The deliberate killing or displacement of a significant part of a population, typically on ethnic or religious grounds. As some examples, Nazi Germany's slaughter of Jewish, Romani, Armenian, gay and other minority people. Serbian slaughter of Muslim people in Kosovo, most notably at Srebenica. Israeli slaughter of Arabic people living in Gaza.
replies(2): >>41862125 #>>41862133 #
SpicyLemonZest[dead post] ◴[] No.41862133[source]
[flagged]
tsimionescu ◴[] No.41862829[source]
What ethnic cleansing of the Arab world's entire Jewish population are you talking about, specifically? Just like in Europe, there have been many waves of better and worse relationships, from relative acceptance to Nazi-like persecution, in various places and at various times, even looking just at the last hundred years.

Still, to a great extent, the biggest contributing factor to the current extremely low Jewish populations in the Middle East outside Israel has been migration or flight to Israel. For example, in Iran, even before the Islamic Revolution and the wave of antisemitic persecution that followed it, which could be described at least as ethnic cleansing if not outright genocide, there had been significant migration of Iranian Jews to Israel.

replies(3): >>41863264 #>>41863519 #>>41865394 #
SpicyLemonZest[dead post] ◴[] No.41863264[source]
[flagged]
1. tsimionescu ◴[] No.41863422[source]
I agree that the line can sometimes be blurry.

But when you directly tell the vast majority of the population of a region (>80%) to flee their homes and migrate south on foot or be killed in bombings, and then still kill more than 20 000 women and children, there is no equivocation. This is genocide.