←back to thread

201 points andsoitis | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0.445s | source
Show context
defrost ◴[] No.41854450[source]
For an interesting side piece:

    Curiously, however, for a system apparently stultified by the dead hand of government, Australia’s health system far outperforms the free market-based US healthcare system, which spends nearly twice as much per capita as Australia to deliver far worse outcomes — including Americans dying five years younger than us.
The shocking truth: Australia has a world-leading health system — because of governments

Source: https://www.crikey.com.au/2024/10/16/pubic-private-healthcar...

Bypass: https://clearthis.page/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.crikey.com.au%2F...

    Overall, we now have the fourth-highest life expectancy in the world.

   This is contrary to the narrative that pervades the media about our health system — one in which our “frontline” health workers heroically battle to overcome government neglect and inadequate spending, while the population is beset by various “epidemics” — obesity, alcohol, illicit drugs.

    In fact, Australian longevity is so remarkable that in August The Economist published a piece simply titled “Why do Australians live so long?”
Other references:

The Economist: https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2024/08/23/why-do-a...

AU Gov Report: Advances in measuring healthcare productivity https://www.pc.gov.au/research/completed/measuring-healthcar...

replies(14): >>41854605 #>>41854613 #>>41854799 #>>41855053 #>>41855120 #>>41855218 #>>41855732 #>>41856242 #>>41856326 #>>41857738 #>>41857930 #>>41857960 #>>41858153 #>>41876405 #
alwayslikethis ◴[] No.41854605[source]
> the free market-based US healthcare system

market, maybe, "free" market? I doubt it.

It's not a very free market when there is such a large power differential between the buyer and the seller. You can't exactly shop around for the ambulance or the hospital when you need it, nor can you realistically circumvent the artificially constrained supply [1] of doctors to get cheaper healthcare (unless you live next to the border).

When the alternative is a one-sided market like this, government becomes rather more appealing.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Medical_Association#R...

replies(7): >>41856252 #>>41856671 #>>41856804 #>>41857003 #>>41857443 #>>41858041 #>>41859036 #
drdec ◴[] No.41857443[source]
>>the free market-based US healthcare system

>market, maybe, "free" market? I doubt it.

The consumer of healthcare is doubly removed from the price of healthcare. This is the opposite of a free market.

The patient did not pay the doctor, the insurance company does. In most cases the patient does not pay for insurance their employer does.

So the normal pricing forces of a free market are removed.

Then we need to talk about certificate of need laws which restrict the supply...

replies(3): >>41857769 #>>41860822 #>>41860950 #
Spooky23 ◴[] No.41857769[source]
The free market aspect is the insurance marketplace.

If you’re poor, you’re fucked. If you’re old you’re ok. If you work for the government or certain companies, you have access to world class care. Everyone else is on a spectrum from high quality PPO to the shittiest Cigna plan.

replies(2): >>41858085 #>>41860734 #
1. 6gvONxR4sf7o ◴[] No.41860734[source]
Even the insurance side isn't really a free market. I've only ever gotten like two choices of insurance provider at any job I've had. More than two plans, but very limited provider choices. You can't get a job offer and then during onboarding say, "sorry, this insurer is unreliable, can we use this other provider instead?"
replies(1): >>41862387 #
2. jandrese ◴[] No.41862387[source]
It is incredibly frustrating to have only one option for insurance provider, and then discover that a solid majority of the health care providers in your area don't take that insurance because they have such a bad reputation.

Then you get into the wonderful world of getting receipts for every procedure and manually submitting them, only for them to be rejected so you have to call and tell them to provide the service they promised you. The insurance isn't even cheap! My monthly deduction would be close to the same price as an Obamacare plan, and that doesn't include the employer contribution. Healthcare is such a racket.