←back to thread

331 points alex_medvedev | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
kgeist ◴[] No.41849906[source]
What does "modern" mean in this context?
replies(4): >>41849987 #>>41849990 #>>41850030 #>>41855909 #
slgeorge ◴[] No.41850030[source]
"Modern" seems to be used a loose adjective these days for "I rewrote $thing [in Rust]". Minecraft was created in 2011, and is Wikipedia says the last version of the 'classic' edition was released in 2017. So anything after 2017 is now defunct.

I don't mind people rewriting things in <insert-name-of-tech-I-like> but "modern" as a value seems pretty loose, and it's often at least arguable whether it's objectively better!

replies(3): >>41850205 #>>41850762 #>>41853865 #
codetrotter ◴[] No.41850205[source]
“Modern” more usually means some new JavaScript thing. In JS land, they consider anything that hasn’t had a commit on main branch in over 3 days to be a dead old project in need of being replaced with something new and “modern” that is up to date with the latest trends and breaking changes from the previous 24 hours of their world.

Usually the hyperbolic superlative for Rust projects is “blazing fast”. Of course, any kind of benchmarks or comparisons with other implementations are completely optional. It is simply enough to “cargo init” and start hammering out code. You don’t even need to consider the characteristics of the algorithms you choose to use! If it’s Rust, it’s “blazing fast”.

replies(2): >>41850435 #>>41850716 #
renewiltord ◴[] No.41850716[source]
Your most starred repo is inferior to a shell one-liner lol. Talk about pot calling the kettle black. Just use the system dict, shuf, grep, and head.

It’s bad form to badmouth someone’s earnest work for sure. I wouldn’t do it normally since I think it’s nice that you actually did something. But if you’re going to sit in a glass house and throw stones you should expect some back.

Fortunately, my house is an underground burrow so I can throw stones with impunity. As ugly as it is to do.

replies(2): >>41851825 #>>41854025 #
1. codetrotter ◴[] No.41851825{3}[source]
> a shell one-liner lol

Dig a little deeper in the repos and you may eventually find that this is exactly what that started as :^)

> badmouth someone’s earnest work for sure

Was speaking generally. Not meant at OP. I think it’s awesome that they are making a Minecraft server in Rust.

> Talk about pot calling the kettle black

Of course! Anything else would be bad form.

> my house is an underground burrow so I can throw stones with impunity

Sneaky, sneaky ;)

replies(1): >>41852032 #
2. renewiltord ◴[] No.41852032[source]
Haha fair play if you’re in the “we’re all clowns here” camp.