←back to thread

424 points notamy | 8 comments | | HN request time: 0.993s | source | bottom
Show context
oblio ◴[] No.41846124[source]
The British are living proof of the fact that amazing things[1] can be achieved when the place you live in is extremely boring.

[1] For varied definitions of "amazing", such as "conquer countries 10x your size", "invent 20 sports the entire world plays", etc.

replies(5): >>41846308 #>>41846396 #>>41846769 #>>41848731 #>>41851219 #
noobermin ◴[] No.41846769[source]
So the bit about UK food being attrocious is unfortunately true from my limited experience but the country itself has a lot of beauty, I think, as long as you look in the roght places.
replies(7): >>41846957 #>>41847568 #>>41847990 #>>41848197 #>>41848242 #>>41849439 #>>41849493 #
dansitu ◴[] No.41848197[source]
Not sure where you've been eating, but even Birmingham—my unfashionable British hometown—has nine Michelin star restaurants within a short drive.

I grew up in the UK but I've lived for 15 years all over the US, and it's always confused me that Americans are convinced that British food is bad. On a whole, British supermarkets have far better produce, in both quality and diversity. UK restaurants run the gamut from cutting edge fine dining and wonderful traditional food to home-grown variants of immigrant cuisine. It's a great place to eat.

My home town is legendary for Indian restaurants—to the extent that Birmingham-style Balti curries have made their way back to India. Before you claim that this is Indian food, not British, can you name an American dish that wasn't developed by immigrants?

Home cooking is far more popular in the UK than the US: anecdotally, most British people cook most meals at home, while few of my American friends know how to boil an egg and rely almost entirely on take-out. British celebrity chefs and cooking shows are famous worldwide. It's odd to claim that British food sucks while binge-watching our prime-time baking show!

I love America and a lot of things are better over here, but food—unfortunately for me—is not one of them.

replies(3): >>41848939 #>>41849273 #>>41851122 #
1. lukas099 ◴[] No.41848939[source]
I think the trope is that British cuisine, that is, dishes that are uniquely British, are bad. Not that there isn’t good food there. Being a rich country, an empire, and part of Europe means you can have many, many different cuisines there though, and like you said many are very good.
replies(3): >>41849095 #>>41849479 #>>41849670 #
2. foldr ◴[] No.41849095[source]
Requiring something to be "uniquely British" to count as British cuisine seems like a pretty high bar. Are burgers and apple pie "uniquely American"? Not sure – and who even cares?
replies(2): >>41849307 #>>41869374 #
3. oblio ◴[] No.41849307[source]
> apple pie "uniquely American"

My Romanian grandma, born in the 1920s, that never traveled more than 100km from her birthplace and never saw even the Black Sea, would beg to differ :-p

replies(1): >>41849329 #
4. sickofparadox ◴[] No.41849329{3}[source]
Such is the cultural reach of America's blue jeans and rock 'n roll.
5. 4dregress ◴[] No.41849479[source]
We have amazing dishes and even more amazing puddings!

I highly recommend you check out this book:

https://www.phaidon.com/store/cookbooks-food-and-drink/the-b...

6. dansitu ◴[] No.41849670[source]
It's a trope for sure, but it doesn't really make sense: a lot of American dishes are traditional British foods. Roast dinners with stuffing and gravy, apple pie, pancakes, biscuits/scones, fried fish and potatoes, meat pies. Thanksgiving dinner is an ancient British harvest feast with some New World ingredients; Christmas dinner is the same format.

And since most American food has also made its way to the UK, there's really not a great deal of difference.

replies(1): >>41869385 #
7. lukas099 ◴[] No.41869374[source]
You’re right, and that’s not the bad I meant to set. More like cuisine that is associated with Britain. So not a French restaurant that happens to be in London.
8. lukas099 ◴[] No.41869385[source]
I don’t think American food is particularly revered either though, is it?