←back to thread

330 points wglb | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
eagerpace ◴[] No.41841031[source]
I am not a doctor and this is not advice. This is a standard medical test I have completely given up on any doctor to perform accurately. I do it myself at home once or twice a month. I do it with the same device, in the same chair, at the same desk, the same time of day, after I’ve ate and drank the same thing. Yes, I still let everyone take it because it’s typically a precondition of receiving care but my readings at home are completely different and give me a more accurate data point that actually makes me feel good about the progress I’ve been making on my health.

I’m actively looking for more healthcare I can do this way. I trust my data and it all coming together on the safety of my personal device. We don’t need doctors with extremely limited datasets to do this and try to find obscure correlations for us.

replies(3): >>41841311 #>>41841557 #>>41842436 #
atahanacar ◴[] No.41842436[source]
>This is a standard medical test I have completely given up on any doctor to perform accurately. I do it myself at home once or twice a month. I do it with the same device, in the same chair, at the same desk, the same time of day, after I’ve ate and drank the same thing.

You are assuming the average patient is this careful about measuring their BP, or anything about their health. You are also assuming the average patient measures their BP correctly, which is obviously untrue as evidenced by some other comments on this post. You are also assuming patients always tell the truth about their own measurements.

>We don’t need doctors with extremely limited datasets to do this and try to find obscure correlations for us.

I don't understand what you mean by this. None of us finds obscure correlations with limited datasets. We don't diagnose someone over a single BP measurement.

replies(1): >>41842670 #
rootusrootus ◴[] No.41842670[source]
> We don't diagnose someone over a single BP measurement.

Yeah I feel like no doctor of mine has ever been the type to do that. My current PCP wouldn't prescribe meds for hypertension until after I took my own BP at home for a month (it was not catastrophically high when measured at his office, he might have taken a different approach in that situation).

replies(2): >>41842804 #>>41843941 #
atahanacar ◴[] No.41842804[source]
Even with a catastrophically high measurement, no doctor would diagnose with a single data point. At worst, they would ask the patient to measure at home multiple times a day, after teaching the correct method of measurement. At best, they would do an ambulatory monitoring.
replies(2): >>41843628 #>>41843889 #
1. Zenzero ◴[] No.41843889[source]
Maybe not a diagnosis, but dependent on history if my patient is throwing repeatable >200 systolic that's probably not one I'm going to just sit on waiting for repeat measurements.