←back to thread

The Stallman Report

(stallman-report.org)
197 points pkilgore | 6 comments | | HN request time: 0.892s | source | bottom
1. cassepipe ◴[] No.41840891[source]
Whether you find the people who want RMS to resign obnoxious or not, this is a very well documented and clear-headed collection of what they think (and convinced me) is wrong with the man
replies(2): >>41847138 #>>41860307 #
2. fsflover ◴[] No.41847138[source]
It isn't. It intentionally gives quotes retracted or out of context.
replies(1): >>41847601 #
3. bayindirh ◴[] No.41847601[source]
Care to elaborate and put them in the proper context?

...and as far as I understood, that comment was not completely retracted, but amended to change the "age bar" to 14?

replies(1): >>41849008 #
4. fsflover ◴[] No.41849008{3}[source]
This: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41847507
replies(1): >>41857473 #
5. bayindirh ◴[] No.41857473{4}[source]
Leaving the mental, emotional and physiological damage of being treated as a "matured adult" the moment you start your 14th year (or puberty) as a human on this planet aside, not because it's small, but it's the contrary.

On the other hand, the freedom of speech does only guarantees that you can tell what you believe openly, but never ever protects you from the consequences of your actions.

Just because some communities believe that entering puberty is enough for these things, it doesn't make it right or harmless. I can find many examples of wrong things which range from funny to atrocious but harmful at the same time.

I'm a big believer of GNU and GPL, and use the four freedoms as the blueprint of what I develop or participate in, however being right and wise in these subjects doesn't make one free from consequences of other actions one may take.

So as a result, linking to a comment telling that being 14 is enough for these things doesn't put the words into context or vindicate the person saying these things.

I may equally say that these words should be punished with a mouth pear (which I do not support in any way, honestly), but we decided that people should be punished in more honorable, better and ethical ways as a planet.

Then, just because some communities prefer mouth pear to this day, it doesn't make the device a legitimate and correct way to punish people.

So, your link to a comment doesn't provide anything in context. Just adds another person who believes in things which are heavily damaging the person who receives this treatment.

6. felipec ◴[] No.41860307[source]
Since when is it a crime to be wrong?