←back to thread

259 points zdw | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
spease ◴[] No.41838425[source]
I’m confused how this is even a question.

With AM, anything that causes a variation in the intensity of the signal will introduce noise.

With FM, anything that causes a variation in the timing of the signal will introduce noise.

Unless you’re traveling at relativistic speeds, operating a time dilation device, or colocated with a black hole, you usually aren’t going to see the rate that time flows at vary.

Thus if you can make the amplitude of your signal irrelevant past a certain threshold and embed all the information into the time domain, the only thing introducing interference should be other EM sources that happen to be on the same channel.

replies(5): >>41838630 #>>41838717 #>>41838999 #>>41839019 #>>41839404 #
1. taeric ◴[] No.41838630[source]
I was surprised this wasn't leaned on more explicitly for the explanation.

I think this is largely held in the assumptions that go into saying most noise will be amplitude modulation?

Edit: Reminds me of the banal but vital insight that digital uses repeaters to gain distance, whereas analog uses amplifiers. Makes it very easy to consider why/how digital took over.