←back to thread

422 points km | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
perching_aix ◴[] No.41831129[source]
Well, at least the title is honest. Straight up asking people to break standards out of sheer conviction is a new one for me personally, but it's definitely one of the attitudes of all time, so maybe it's just me being green.

Can we ask for the typical *nix text editors to disobey the POSIX standard of a text file next, so that I don't need to use hex editing to get trailing newlines off the end of files?

replies(4): >>41831233 #>>41831275 #>>41831592 #>>41833146 #
rkeene2 ◴[] No.41831275[source]
People don't seem to mind when Chrome does it [0]. The response "standards aren't a death pact" stands out in particular.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13860682

replies(2): >>41831414 #>>41833103 #
perching_aix ◴[] No.41831414[source]
Might be just my personal impression, but I'm pretty sure Chrome is extremely notorious for abusing its market leader position, including in this way. So gonna have to disagree there, from my view people do mind Chrome and its implementation particularities quite a lot.
replies(1): >>41831905 #
dijit ◴[] No.41831905[source]
I think the parent is equally denigrating the situation.

Leaders choose the standards, especially as they approach monopoly.

Worse still: people will come out of the woodwork to actively defend the monopolist de facto standard producer.

replies(1): >>41831972 #
nsnshsuejeb ◴[] No.41831972[source]
Not defending the producer, just making pragmatic choices!
replies(1): >>41833497 #
1. dwattttt ◴[] No.41833497{3}[source]
Pragmatic choices is what Postel is known for now, and it makes for a pretty confused world when everyone makes different pragmatic choices.