←back to thread

552 points freedomben | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.257s | source
Show context
emaro ◴[] No.41809865[source]
For people that have somehow missed the story, manifest v3 removed support for certain powerful network apis, severly limiting ad-blockers capabilities. uBlock Origin will not work anymore without manifest v2 (there's a v3 compatible lite version of uBlock Origin).
replies(2): >>41810024 #>>41810092 #
btown ◴[] No.41810092[source]
It's worth noting that the maintenance of the "lite" version is at some nonzero risk of burnout for its developers, ironically in part due to Mozilla being unnecessarily hostile: https://github.com/uBlockOrigin/uBOL-home/issues/197#issueco... discussed at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41707418 - and while there's no plan yet to discontinue the Chrome MV3 compatible version, there are a million ways that this could go wrong.

My only long-term hope for this space is that a nonzero segment of congressional representatives have had ad blockers installed by their aides, realize that their experience online takes a nosedive when MV2 is discontinued, and calls for hearings! Blocking isn't just about not seeing ads, it's about a user's freedom to set up their "user agent" to preserve their privacy online from sites that don't respect their wishes. That's a right that Google is using its market power to erode, and it's not something we should take sitting down.

More on MV3 from a few years ago: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2021/12/chrome-users-beware-ma...

replies(6): >>41812158 #>>41814592 #>>41815400 #>>41815495 #>>41816001 #>>41816859 #
sockaddr ◴[] No.41814592[source]
I think everywhere that you used “nonzero” you could have also not and it would have still made exactly the same point.
replies(1): >>41814887 #
btown ◴[] No.41814887[source]
Normally this kind of thing isn’t said in good faith, but it’s actually a way my writing can improve and I appreciate the feedback!
replies(1): >>41825596 #
1. sockaddr ◴[] No.41825596[source]
To be honest, the reason I mentioned it at all was because I do the same thing with the same word so it was as much of a comment for your benefit as it was for my benefit haha.