←back to thread

420 points rvz | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
Adrian_Ferreira ◴[] No.41414410[source]
I'm from Brazil and this judge is totally out of control. I agree that X needs to have a legal representative in Brazil, this is correct anywhere, but he threatened a fine of 200k and imprisonment to the person Musk appointed as representative if his stricture orders were not complied with. He threatened us to pay $9k in fines per day if we use VPN to access X. Unless you are part of the government base, it is difficult to find someone who approves of his actions.
replies(7): >>41414425 #>>41414535 #>>41415073 #>>41415211 #>>41417518 #>>41417551 #>>41417842 #
Adrian_Ferreira ◴[] No.41414425[source]
72% of Brazilians do not agree with the banning of X: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9UleMSw8m3o
replies(4): >>41414460 #>>41415412 #>>41415680 #>>41417847 #
yokoprime ◴[] No.41415680[source]
This is an excellent example of how statistics can be manipulated. Of course people don’t want to ban a service they use, but if the question had been “is it ok for foreign companies offering services to Brazilian citizens to ignore Brazilian law” the result would probably be different
replies(1): >>41417034 #
onlyrealcuzzo ◴[] No.41417034[source]
And it would further be a different result if the question was:

"Is it ok for foreign companies offering services to Brazilian citizens to ignore Brazilian law? Even if that company is Twitter and it means you lose access to Twitter?"

The average person does not really care about what's right or wrong or fair - just what's in their interest.

The average person cannot or does not think - "But what if a bunch of other companies were doing this thing? What if we had to treat them all fairly?"

That's why it's good when you have a legal system that at least attempts to be fair - instead of just populist and doing whatever people want.

replies(2): >>41417989 #>>41418287 #
1. lanstin ◴[] No.41417989{3}[source]
I know a fair number of people and most of them do visibly struggle with what is right or wrong at times. Cooperation is very much a mainstay of human behavior. Or of course some people believe that what is good is also in their own interest, long term and considering the effect posing what you believe is wrong has on your own self. They do things believing them to be good and also in their interests. But they certainly don't ignore what is good.