←back to thread

631 points wojtczyk | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
rgovostes ◴[] No.41411031[source]
I can usually appreciate Apple's design homages. The original iOS Calculator is inspired by the Braun ET, and it makes some sense to provide a familiar design for basic use.

But it inherits baggage from the limitations of the handheld calculators of the 1970s. Why can't I use the - button to write a negative sign? What does "AC" mean? The scientific calculator is an even worse design. There's a ton of invisible state, like the value stored in memory, or whether you're inside parentheses. The user has to hold the whole sequence of operations in their head, without clicking a single wrong button. Want to repeat a calculation with a different operand? Tough.

Graphing calculators like the TI-84 that let you see and edit your input are so much more usable. Even better are notebook-style interfaces like Mathematica. It's a shame Apple won't pay homage to those designs.

replies(1): >>41411129 #
FabHK ◴[] No.41411129[source]
Coming up in iOS 18.
replies(1): >>41411530 #
rgovostes ◴[] No.41411530[source]
Unless I missed something, they’ve added a handwriting mode, which is cool but not necessarily an improvement over something like Mathematica. I don’t want to have to carry an Apple Pencil with me and write long hand every time I want to solve an equation.
replies(1): >>41412372 #
1. rgovostes ◴[] No.41412372{3}[source]
I did miss something, you can type in Math Notes in iOS 18. It’s a little glitchy in the betas though.