←back to thread

181 points EndXA | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.2s | source
Show context
londons_explore ◴[] No.40727286[source]
I wish designers of vehicles - particularly cars, trains and busses, would work to minimize jerk, snap and crackle.

Turns out if you minimize those, you get a far more comfortable ride. It matters far more than acceleration.

Finite element models of the whole system (tyres and suspension components and flexing elements of the vehicle body and road/track) can quickly allow analysis of the jerk, snap and crackle, and allow tuning of damping and drive system control loops to make a far more comfortable ride.

replies(3): >>40727304 #>>40728030 #>>40730913 #
constantcrying ◴[] No.40728030[source]
>I wish designers of vehicles - particularly cars, trains and busses, would work to minimize jerk, snap and crackle.

They do.

>Turns out if you minimize those, you get a far more comfortable ride. It matters far more than acceleration.

They know that this is the case. And put a lot of effort into making sure your car has the desired feel.

Besides your comfort these considerations are extremely important for the durability analysis for the vehicle.

>Finite element models of the whole system (tyres and suspension components and flexing elements of the vehicle body and road/track) can quickly allow analysis of the jerk, snap and crackle, and allow tuning of damping and drive system control loops to make a far more comfortable ride.

Finite element simulations are undesirable, they are extremely calculation expensive for those kind of large models and somewhat unsuitable. They are used in crash tests.

For the application you described multi body systems are used, where the car is decomposed into its functional components, which can be modeled either as stiff or flexible. With that you have a reasonably accurate model of a car which you can use to test on a virtual test track.

Basically every competent car manufacturer is doing this.

replies(2): >>40729433 #>>40733474 #
1. p1mrx ◴[] No.40733474[source]
I recently rode the Blue Line in Chicago, and found the jumps in acceleration to be quite jarring. Some of that is due to the track, but it felt like the majority could be fixed using a modern motor controller and a bit of math.