←back to thread

181 points EndXA | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
londons_explore ◴[] No.40727286[source]
I wish designers of vehicles - particularly cars, trains and busses, would work to minimize jerk, snap and crackle.

Turns out if you minimize those, you get a far more comfortable ride. It matters far more than acceleration.

Finite element models of the whole system (tyres and suspension components and flexing elements of the vehicle body and road/track) can quickly allow analysis of the jerk, snap and crackle, and allow tuning of damping and drive system control loops to make a far more comfortable ride.

replies(3): >>40727304 #>>40728030 #>>40730913 #
amelius ◴[] No.40727304[source]
Do you have proof for that, or is this like audiophiles asking for gold connectors because "they make the sound better"?
replies(7): >>40727367 #>>40727380 #>>40727443 #>>40727865 #>>40727925 #>>40727926 #>>40728053 #
setopt ◴[] No.40727380[source]
Anecdotal evidence:

Ever experienced that a bus is braking (near-constant deacceleration), and people seem fine; but then the bus comes to a halt and thus stops deaccelerating, and people suddenly fall on the floor?

I think at least the derivative or acceleration is important for how well people can compensate. Not sure about higher derivatives though.

replies(2): >>40727607 #>>40731289 #
amelius ◴[] No.40727607[source]
Acceleration equals force, so yeah, if you abruptly change acceleration then this equals abruptly changing the force on people in the bus. Acceleration should thus be continuous (not necessarily differentiable). I don't know how you would justify constraints on higher derivatives. Perhaps they mess with our own internal control mechanism?
replies(1): >>40727774 #
ccccccc1 ◴[] No.40727774{3}[source]
is it physically possible to have non-continuous acceleration?
replies(3): >>40727994 #>>40728677 #>>40729197 #
1. amelius ◴[] No.40729197{4}[source]
Voltages can change abruptly. Therefore, forces can change abruptly, and hence acceleration as well.