←back to thread

Software Friction

(www.hillelwayne.com)
141 points saikatsg | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.215s | source
Show context
taeric ◴[] No.40722235[source]
I am surprised by discussions, so far. Which, at the moment appear to be people poking holes in the shortcomings of friction as a model, and then a few talking about the unreasonable effectiveness of some processes.

My surprise is that neither discussion really leans in on the metaphor. Friction, as a metaphor, is really strong as the way you deal with things vastly changes the more mature a technology is. Consider how much extra lubricant is necessary in early combustion engines compared to more modern electric motors.

More, as you cannot always hope to eliminate the external cause of friction, you can design around it in different ways. Either by controlling what parts of a system are more frequently replaced , or by eliminating the need for them entirely, if and when you can. You can trace the different parts of a modern car to see how this has progressed.

Indeed, the modern car is a wonderful exploration, as we had some technologies that came and went entirely to deal with operator involvement. Manual transmissions largely were replaced by automatic for a variety of reasons, not the least of which was wear and tear on the clutch. And it seems to be going away entirely due to the nature of electric motors being so different from combustion ones?

replies(2): >>40722422 #>>40722454 #
prerok ◴[] No.40722454[source]
Just FYI, in Europe we mostly use manual transmission and clutch is mostly so robust that something else breaks way before that.

Also, a lot of auto transmission approaches use the clutch behind the scenes, at least in the older models. But, I am nitpicking here at the analogy being transferred to the clutch system.

I fully agree otherwise that the friction is the best term to describe what is happening across the system and within social interactions.

replies(1): >>40722990 #
1. taeric ◴[] No.40722990[source]
Right, this is part of my assertion to the metaphor. There is not, necessarily, a single solution that is obviously superior to others. You can get lucky and find one, of course. Often times, though, it is largely driven by what tradeoffs can be made.