←back to thread

960 points andrew918277 | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.218s | source
Show context
loftsy ◴[] No.40716004[source]
It should be possible to have a private chat without spying.

However I have an unpopular opinion, interested to hear what others might think:

We should eliminate anonymity online. If you go on the internet everything you do should be tied back to your name. This can be done using device attestation. Everyone gets a private key tied to their name/address.

This is compatible with free speech. In fact it promotes free speech because being a "troll" becomes a lot more personal.

I think this way of living would be closer to our nature as tribal primates. It would improve behaviour and overall quality of life. Our brains are designed to have checks and balances from wider society which you don't get anonymously online.

This would also reduce the need for govt monitoring because any chat online could be "turned in" by an informer and then any criminals identified.

replies(11): >>40716015 #>>40716022 #>>40716023 #>>40716030 #>>40716038 #>>40716291 #>>40716385 #>>40716899 #>>40717312 #>>40718614 #>>40725073 #
piva00 ◴[] No.40716030[source]
> This would also reduce the need for govt monitoring because any chat online could be "turned in" by an informer and then any criminals identified.

This is where you completely break your premise, this is Stasi levels of informing, asking for the population to spy on each other. It's not healthy to society when you feel that any other person you interact with might be informing on you to the State, you leave a very wide avenue open for misuse when the State changes its rulings on what's considered criminal.

replies(1): >>40716346 #
1. loftsy ◴[] No.40716346[source]
Maybe.

How is it different from now when you can record a conversation you have? or forward an email to the police?