←back to thread

380 points rezonant | 5 comments | | HN request time: 0.294s | source
Show context
anileated ◴[] No.40208302[source]
Do I think side-loading and alt app stores would make iPads and iPhones more versatile devices? Yes.

Do I believe indie devs will be worse off? Unfortunately, also yes.

If you are a solo app developer, you will now have to keep presence on all app stores out there, since if you don’t publish on one then a copycat will. Every store would have its own review processes, fee structures, billing and tax procedures. Since you would need to follow a dozen of those, as an indie operation realistically you will either go under or pay middleman companies a chunk for this—so, in the end, you’ll lose the same cut or more and we’re back to the starting point.

Furthermore, I believe you will have much less protection against plain piracy, which was a big thing in the days of yore until it was spectacularly dealt with by Apple within its mobile ecosystem.

This is why I suspect the primary interests side-loading and alt app stores on Apple devices would satisfy is large enterprises and a few opportunistic middlemen. Entities like Epic, Netflix, who will be able to generate more profit; governments, perhaps; a few publishing companies (think CDBaby for apps) will win small time; some users who don’t want to pay and want to get things for free might be able to get their way; indie devs will be worse off.

replies(16): >>40208353 #>>40208448 #>>40208458 #>>40208518 #>>40208520 #>>40208529 #>>40208559 #>>40208626 #>>40208630 #>>40208693 #>>40208746 #>>40208979 #>>40209032 #>>40210376 #>>40210772 #>>40220048 #
1. pjerem ◴[] No.40208529[source]
This is already mitigated with copyright laws.

If a copycat is using your brand, you’ll have zero issue removing them from any App Store. If a copycat is just copying your app, well, that’s called a competitor.

replies(2): >>40208589 #>>40211347 #
2. kgc ◴[] No.40208589[source]
Indie devs typically won’t have the resources to monitor and react to a constant flow of copycats.
replies(2): >>40208643 #>>40208688 #
3. blackoil ◴[] No.40208643[source]
No one copies small indie apps. Copying makes sense only with popular apps.

Also, web is very open ecosystem and phishing is a problem but for users and corporate, not for small devs

4. viraptor ◴[] No.40208688[source]
If it's a common issue, services for automatic multi-store deployment and checks like that will appear very soon.
5. labcomputer ◴[] No.40211347[source]
And if the store is hosted outside of Europe? Just like how nobody can access the pirate bay?