←back to thread

Scale of the Universe

(scaleofuniverse.com)
249 points Leftium | 6 comments | | HN request time: 2.487s | source | bottom
Show context
NayamAmarshe ◴[] No.40084790[source]
I love the end of it, just a big circle of random static noise. Looking at stuff like this always brings up the question of why does anything exist at all?
replies(4): >>40084978 #>>40085027 #>>40086145 #>>40088518 #
kaashif ◴[] No.40086145[source]
What kind of answer could even possibly answer that question?

Any answer is subject to the follow-up question, well why does that thing exist? Why did that happen?

If a question cannot be answered, there's no point in asking it I think.

Other questions about the physical laws governing the big bang or inflation or black holes can be answered, although they might be very difficult to answer.

replies(5): >>40086206 #>>40086375 #>>40086435 #>>40086551 #>>40088111 #
mistermann ◴[] No.40086551[source]
> Any answer is subject to the follow-up question, well why does that thing exist? Why did that happen?

Various kinds of faith (religious, scientific, etc) can stop infinite regress.

> If a question cannot be answered, there's no point in asking it I think.

Easy peasy.

replies(1): >>40090266 #
1. kaashif ◴[] No.40090266[source]
Faith can stop you asking the question of why God exists rather than nothing, but it can't actually answer that question.
replies(2): >>40091716 #>>40092699 #
2. NayamAmarshe ◴[] No.40091716[source]
The moment we ask why, it has to have a reason. However Vedānta for example, would argue that brahman or the entity that is the cause of all causes, is causeless in itself. There can be no other explanation.

If something has a cause then it's ruled by cause and effect. If something is causeless, it not only does not need a reason to exist but is also the entity that puts forth cause and effect in motion. Kinda similar to Aristotle's concept of the prime mover.

replies(1): >>40139450 #
3. mistermann ◴[] No.40092699[source]
It can certainly answer it, but whether it can answer it accurately is another matter.

To make it even trickier: it isn't only religious people who are affected by faith, though clever word play, cultural norms, etc can make it appear otherwise.

4. mistermann ◴[] No.40139450[source]
A contrasting take on it afaict:

https://share.snipd.com/chapter/ceddc8a8-939b-48c7-8cea-45d7...

replies(1): >>40149822 #
5. NayamAmarshe ◴[] No.40149822{3}[source]
Doesn't seem much contrasting. Dao concept sounds quite similar to the concept of Dharma outlaid in Bhagavad Gita.

Wu-Wei sounds very much like Karma Yoga and Yin-Yang too. It's all very much like the teachings of the Bhagavad Gita.

replies(1): >>40259556 #
6. mistermann ◴[] No.40259556{4}[source]
Contrast the uncertain sentiment in your last comment with "has to have" and various other "facts" of questionable origin above.