←back to thread

517 points xbar | 10 comments | | HN request time: 1.204s | source | bottom
1. golf_mike ◴[] No.39146071[source]
How is this hackernews?
replies(5): >>39146184 #>>39146195 #>>39146719 #>>39146846 #>>39148454 #
2. dang ◴[] No.39146184[source]
HN's approach to stories with political overlap has been stable for many years*. I've written about it many times: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so....

If you read some of those past explanations and still have a question about our general approach, let me know what it is. As for this particular story, I turned off the flags on it because it clearly counts as SNI (significant new information - https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so...).

* as has the question "how is this hackernews", of course: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17014869

replies(2): >>39147534 #>>39147591 #
3. hightrix ◴[] No.39146195[source]
Like everything else on this site, you are welcome to ignore it if the topic does not interest you.
replies(1): >>39149773 #
4. objektif ◴[] No.39146719[source]
You are ok to talk about pizza recipes on github but not about most important geopolitical events in the world?
replies(1): >>39146879 #
5. bdcravens ◴[] No.39146846[source]
How is anything? One could argue that real estate occupancy in San Francisco isn't hackernews.

I think there's an intellectual interest here, but the line is very blurry with politics. It's probably as blurry as the articles posted about US being a surveillance state, cryptocurrency articles unrelated to the technology itself, etc.

6. dang ◴[] No.39146879[source]
Can you please stop posting in the flamewar style? It's against HN's rules, and especially against the intended spirit that I tried to describe at the top of this thread.

Obviously most of what gets discussed on HN is relatively unimportant in the world. If that weren't the case, HN would simply be a current affairs site, which it isn't. At the same time, that doesn't mean every political story is off topic here—the guidelines already make that clear by their use of the word "most": https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.

There's a long and pretty consistent history to how HN handles the question of political topics.

7. golf_mike ◴[] No.39147534[source]
Thanks, I guess Hackernews generally is my 'safe haven' from politics. Really not intending to bite or insult, just a lot happier reading about Dijkstra being a pedantic nano-Dijkstrahole or someone dumping a GBA rom through audio. The stuff from OP I read everywhere else. My heart cries for the for the world and HN generally is one of my tissues. Much love anyways.
8. theferalrobot ◴[] No.39147591[source]
Yet you banned all the posts on Oct 7?
replies(1): >>39148770 #
9. eej71 ◴[] No.39148770{3}[source]
You aren't the only one who has noticed.
10. golf_mike ◴[] No.39149773[source]
I guess the same goes for comments :)