←back to thread

The midwit home

(dynomight.substack.com)
416 points stacktrust | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
marcinzm ◴[] No.37860179[source]
>The hell? But people seem to think that Home Assistant is good. (Something about subscription fees and invasive apps and forced obsolescence?) So you search for “how to get a Home Assistant”. This reveals a recursive landscape of terror:

Google "how to install home assistant" which leads to:

>https://www.home-assistant.io/installation/

>If you are unsure of what to choose, follow the Raspberry Pi guide to install Home Assistant Operating System.

This leads to:

>https://www.home-assistant.io/installation/raspberrypi

This has a nice visual guide that requires you to know how to buy a raspberry pi, how to plug in a raspberry p, how to plug in an sd card (twice), and how to navigate to a url.

replies(3): >>37860217 #>>37860314 #>>37860534 #
barbazoo ◴[] No.37860217[source]
I felt like that was a big strawman. HA in particular makes it very easy to chose how to install, they even a product you can buy that's ready to use (HA Yellow).
replies(5): >>37860438 #>>37860488 #>>37860681 #>>37861019 #>>37861338 #
mason55 ◴[] No.37861019[source]
> HA in particular makes it very easy to chose how to install

This is the problem with lots of stuff similar to HA when it tries to break into a non-enthusiast audience: people don't WANT to choose how to install it. Most of the time they have no clue why they would choose one thing over another and giving them those choices is confusing and overwhelming.

It's like starting a an intro to Nix tutorial with by asking if the user wants to enable flakes.

I say this as a very active user of HA & Nix for 5+ years.

replies(1): >>37861115 #
1. belval ◴[] No.37861115{3}[source]
With HA it doesn't help that their installation docs are a mess with solutions that don't provide the same features.

I've had HA for +4-5 years too.