←back to thread

Hacker News Guidelines

(news.ycombinator.com)
446 points tonmoy | 7 comments | | HN request time: 0.424s | source | bottom
1. nailer ◴[] No.37252399[source]
> Please submit the original source. If a post reports on something found on another site, submit the latter.

This means whenever Microsoft announce something or someone writes about something on Twitter, submit that instead of theverge.com.

replies(2): >>37252792 #>>37253073 #
2. crazygringo ◴[] No.37252792[source]
The problem is that press releases often only give one side of a "story", while news articles often present it in a valuable narrative context.

E.g. a new product was announced because the old one used to catch fire. I mean the context isn't usually that dramatic, but there's often important information about a price change, or a response to previous consumer complaints, or how it fits into the broader product line, or is a response to competition -- all of which is much more valuable than anything in a press release.

replies(2): >>37254756 #>>37260878 #
3. minimaxir ◴[] No.37253073[source]
This is a weird gray area where although Twitter/X is the canonical source for many announcements, users don't upvote them unless it's from a more respected domain. (and often with a more informative title)
replies(1): >>37254582 #
4. callalex ◴[] No.37254582[source]
It’s not about respect for the domain, it’s the fact that the website is outright broken and I cannot view the content that was linked to.
replies(1): >>37254626 #
5. minimaxir ◴[] No.37254626{3}[source]
It was the case well before Elon acquired it.
6. arp242 ◴[] No.37254756[source]
Press releases are basically just advertisements.
7. nailer ◴[] No.37260878[source]
Sure, but that’s what journalists do - verge articles are just repeats of the original source with nothing added other than a clickbait headline and larger images.