Most active commenters

    ←back to thread

    252 points kosasbest | 16 comments | | HN request time: 0.639s | source | bottom
    1. taitems ◴[] No.37204057[source]
    It took me 4 rounds to realise the time input was a slider, as you couldn't click to type. It needs some work.
    replies(12): >>37204093 #>>37204130 #>>37204617 #>>37205245 #>>37205401 #>>37206029 #>>37206406 #>>37206893 #>>37207447 #>>37208686 #>>37208861 #>>37209451 #
    2. drawkbox ◴[] No.37204093[source]
    Yeah the slider really needs to be called out better, looked like part of a design notch.

    Other than that, pretty fun trivia game and includes some historical content.

    3. jtagen ◴[] No.37204130[source]
    Holy crap, I spent way too much time trying to type text or figure out why it changed state when you clicked on it.
    replies(1): >>37206741 #
    4. StevePerkins ◴[] No.37204617[source]
    Oh my God, thank you! That was infuriating. This twist on Geoguessr is an awesome concept, but that UX detail really needs a re-think.
    5. Aeroi ◴[] No.37205245[source]
    it took me 4 rounds to realize that as well
    replies(1): >>37206011 #
    6. kmoser ◴[] No.37205401[source]
    (41,991 points!) And why does the year default to 1962?
    replies(1): >>37206988 #
    7. ◴[] No.37206011[source]
    8. abainbridge ◴[] No.37206029[source]
    The same game (almost) with the same slider (almost) is not at all confusing: https://www.chronophoto.app/game.html

    Getting the subtle elements of a UI wrong have a profound effect.

    9. dclowd9901 ◴[] No.37206406[source]
    I definitely put a pin on the coast of the UK too and it ended up somewhere in northern France after I submitted my guess.
    10. cellover ◴[] No.37206741[source]
    Same here, I had to right-click > inspect to know how the field was working :-D
    11. pcdoodle ◴[] No.37206893[source]
    Flat UI strikes again!

    Let's learn a new control appearance for every website.

    12. mojo74 ◴[] No.37206988[source]
    The slider only goes back to 1900 and up to 2023 so 1962 halfway between the two?
    13. mp3il ◴[] No.37207447[source]
    exactly the same here. bad UX
    14. ptdorf ◴[] No.37208686[source]
    I came here for this.
    15. thiht ◴[] No.37208861[source]
    On the first round I thought it was an input, then I realized it must be a slider but I tried to use it wrong. I only persisted on my second guess and realized it was actually a slider, but it didn't work how I expected.

    It was really confusing that it's called timeguessr but asks me to guess the location

    Agree, this is bad UI

    16. rob74 ◴[] No.37209451[source]
    Interesting, I didn't have a problem with that - maybe it's because my monitor is calibrated juuuust right so I can see the extremely-light-gray bar behind the red slider? Maybe making that more visible and making the slider not blend in with the red background of the year would be enough?