←back to thread

340 points agomez314 | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0.004s | source
Show context
jvanderbot ◴[] No.35245898[source]
Memorization is absolutely the most valuable part of GPT, for me. I can get natural language responses to documentation, basic scripting / sysadmin, and API questions much more easily than searching other ways.

While this is an academic interest point, and rightly tamps down on hype around replacing humans, it doesn't dissuade what I think are most peoples' basic use case: "I don't know or don't remember how to do X, can you show me?"

This is finally a good enough "knowledge reference engine" that I can see being useful to those very people it is over hyped to replace.

replies(6): >>35245958 #>>35245959 #>>35245985 #>>35246065 #>>35246167 #>>35252251 #
soco ◴[] No.35246167[source]
Good luck getting ChatGPT to explain a cron expression like "0 30 5 * * 3". I mean, it will explain, but mixing up everything. How many other mistakes it might make?
replies(7): >>35246247 #>>35246250 #>>35246277 #>>35246542 #>>35247089 #>>35248460 #>>35248921 #
messe ◴[] No.35246250[source]
Isn't that an invalid cron expression? It has six fields instead of five, and says to run at the 30th hour of the day.
replies(1): >>35246476 #
soco ◴[] No.35246476[source]
It's a valid Quartz scheduler task where it starts with the seconds. But right, I shouldn't have asked ChatGPT about cron when it's actually quartz - and indeed with the changed prompt it will describe it correctly.

Edit: actually almost correctly: " - '3' represents the day of the week on which the task will be executed. In this case, the value is 3, which represents Wednesday (Sunday is 1, Monday is 2, and so on)."

replies(1): >>35248998 #
1. jldugger ◴[] No.35248998[source]
Lol, GPT exposing bugs in the wetware
replies(1): >>35259306 #
2. soco ◴[] No.35259306[source]
Actually, no. It gave a wrong answer in full confidence then HN analyzed it to expose the bug(s).