←back to thread

1345 points philosopher1234 | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
zactato ◴[] No.34631181[source]
I remember playing one of the early CS betas as a Half-life mod in ~1999. It was such a huge leap in gameplay and style from anything else out there.

Most FPSs up to this point were SciFi based, guns like the BFG and plasma guns. Counterstrike's focus on realism really altered how you connected with the game. Columbine had happened very recently and was still very much in the zeitgeist. There was a very real cultural attack on video games as a scapegoat for the massacre.

My friends and I would build CounterStrike maps that were the layout of our highschool and would then run around and shoot each other. This was very taboo at the time. We knew that this would be interpreted as threatening by the powers-that-be at highschool, but it was exciting.

replies(25): >>34631550 #>>34631571 #>>34632235 #>>34632410 #>>34632421 #>>34632662 #>>34632744 #>>34633225 #>>34633311 #>>34633601 #>>34633630 #>>34634538 #>>34635016 #>>34635226 #>>34636622 #>>34636802 #>>34636887 #>>34636896 #>>34637086 #>>34637342 #>>34638067 #>>34638234 #>>34647230 #>>34649745 #>>34686529 #
geph2021 ◴[] No.34632235[source]

   We knew that this would be interpreted as threatening by the powers-that-be at highschool
These days that kind of behavior, if reported to law enforcement (mandatory reporting in some cases), will get investigated with the potential for criminal charges, and likely school expulsion.
replies(2): >>34632469 #>>34633414 #
sneak ◴[] No.34632469[source]
I wonder if that's legal, given that mapmaking is protected expression, and a recent ruling saying that (public) schools can't police protected expression off of school grounds.

Without a clear expression of threat, I don't think simple mapmaking is sufficient grounds for a terror threat charge.

replies(1): >>34632775 #
vuln ◴[] No.34632775[source]
> simple mapmaking

It's not simple mapmaking though is it? It's creating a map inside a video game to simulate school grounds.

Drawing a map of the school and putting it in a frame on your wall? Fine.

Drawing a map, recreating it inside a first person shooter, then spending hours playing (training) memorizing the map? I believe anyone could see that as a terroristic threat.

Edit: Example Legos. Having a Lego model of the US Capital? Fine

Have a Lego Capital, attend the Jan 6 protest, have books and other militia type information? Probably going to get questioned by the feds.

https://www.businessinsider.com/fbi-took-lego-set-of-capitol...

replies(7): >>34632979 #>>34634172 #>>34634383 #>>34634680 #>>34637120 #>>34638957 #>>34639777 #
lstamour ◴[] No.34632979[source]
I think you might also need to consider the context though - well before the thought of a “school shooting” was an annual occurrence. If schools had metal detectors it was for knives or worst case, a hand gun. And guns themselves are not universally liked or practiced with. I seriously doubt someone would suggest that playing an fy_ map is grounds for practicing anything except video games. Extending a video game to reproducing a school ground or neighbourhood seems natural - when I wanted to make my first text based game, I tried making it about different rooms of my house, for example. People often want to model the world around them just to see if they can.
replies(1): >>34633123 #
vuln ◴[] No.34633123[source]
What about the context of flying a commercial airliner into a skyscraper?

Moussaoui enrolled in a flight simulator training course at a Pan Am facility near Minneapolis, Minnesota. Pan Am’s Minneapolis facility used flight simulators only, and the training there usually consisted of initial training for newly hired airline pilots or refresher training for active pilots.

https://oig.justice.gov/sites/default/files/archive/special/...

replies(2): >>34633209 #>>34633521 #
1. jml7c5 ◴[] No.34633521{3}[source]
It's a Cessna rather than a commercial airliner, but slamming a plane into landmark buildings was not tabo or out of the ordinary pre-9/11: https://youtu.be/ssig3LUCwng?t=4m35s.
replies(1): >>34635856 #
2. CrazyPyroLinux ◴[] No.34635856[source]
Indeed - Tom Clancy wrote Debt of Honor long before 9/11, and Rainbow Six long before COVID.