←back to thread

1444 points feross | 7 comments | | HN request time: 0.908s | source | bottom
Show context
TazeTSchnitzel ◴[] No.32641381[source]
It's really interesting that such a bland, un-subversive show whose only mentions of sensitive topics are in bad throwaway jokes is so heavily censored. I guess a more interesting show would just not get aired at all.
replies(11): >>32641593 #>>32641959 #>>32641967 #>>32642113 #>>32642265 #>>32642275 #>>32642430 #>>32642432 #>>32642533 #>>32642820 #>>32643185 #
sltkr ◴[] No.32641967[source]
Personally I'm mostly offended how stale and unoriginal a lot of these jokes are, but I can definitely see why the censors took offense at some of them.

For example, the joke about the Chinese restaurant ("I'd be more concerned about what they're passing off as chicken") plays off of the stereotype that Chinese people eat dogs and cats, and the “passing off” remark implies that the Chinese restaurant owners are deceptive and would immorally and illegally serve their guests a different kind of meat than advertised. I can definitely see how that joke would be considered offensive.

The author labels that joke as "harmless" but you don't have to be a Chinese censor to interpret it as reinforcing harmful stereotypes. I dare you to show that scene at a liberal college and notice how few laughs you get.

Similarly, the racist remarks about Chinese people made by Sheldon's mom are somewhat offensive if taken at face value. I guess the joke is supposed to be at her expense instead ("old people are racists" is an American comedy cliche, if a somewhat tired one) but it's conceivable that either the censors didn't get that, or they feared that their audience didn't get that, so they decided to cut it out entirely.

"They wouldn't get that" is probably also the right explanation for censoring the joke about Jews eating at Chinese restaurants during Christmas, which is a very American tradition. That doesn't imply the joke needs to go, but I can see how that would, at best, leave Chinese viewers scratching their heads.

replies(14): >>32642023 #>>32642126 #>>32642156 #>>32642213 #>>32642279 #>>32642286 #>>32642594 #>>32642617 #>>32642729 #>>32642795 #>>32642889 #>>32643010 #>>32644101 #>>32644466 #
jedberg ◴[] No.32642213[source]
> I dare you to show that scene at a liberal college and notice how few laughs you get.

Did you see the recent video where the white guy dressed up in a poncho, big hat, and fake mustache and carried around maracas? He asked a bunch of white kids on a college campus if they thought his outfit was offensive to Mexicans, and they all said yes.

Then he went to the Mexican part of town and asked actual Mexicans, and they all said it was funny or that they liked that he was trying to honor their culture. Not one of them was offended.

So perhaps it would be good to ask a Chinese person if this joke offends them.

replies(7): >>32642299 #>>32642307 #>>32642311 #>>32642440 #>>32642938 #>>32644507 #>>32645194 #
jacobsenscott ◴[] No.32642440[source]
No, but I constantly hear right wingers referencing it. It must be very popular in the echo chamber.
replies(1): >>32642480 #
1. jedberg ◴[] No.32642480[source]
Yes, it does support a right wing point of view, but that doesn't mean it's necessarily wrong. It's just one video, but there are many other videos and essays about the same topic.
replies(2): >>32642592 #>>32655937 #
2. wizofaus ◴[] No.32642592[source]
What "right wing point of view" exactly? That racism isn't a real problem? Are there mainstream right-wing organisations that actually promote that view?
replies(2): >>32642659 #>>32642689 #
3. jedberg ◴[] No.32642659[source]
The right wing uses videos like that to show that, "liberals are the only ones offended by cultural appropriation". The topic is far too complex to be encapsulated in a TikTok video, but the video is just an example of how it's possible that representing another culture could still be appreciated, and that not every instance of representing another culture is appropriation.
4. dogleash ◴[] No.32642689[source]
No. The point of view that between being maximally uptight about race is different than acknowledging and working against racism.
replies(2): >>32642737 #>>32642850 #
5. wizofaus ◴[] No.32642737{3}[source]
That's my point of view and I don't consider myself the least bit right wing!
6. Banana699 ◴[] No.32642850{3}[source]
This is called Common Sense. To the extent that it's right-wing-coded in (and, I believe, only in) USA is only a reflection of how wacko their pseudo-left has gone.
7. jacobsenscott ◴[] No.32655937[source]
This guy simply edits videos to provoke a reaction and get clicks. It is just business, and not an accurate depiction of reality at all.

It isn't even a creative or original idea. Remember Jimmy Kimmel's "The Man Show" where he got women on the street to sign an "End suffrage now!" petition because "suffrage" sounds like "suffering"?

It is an easy trick to embarrass people by shoving a camera in their face and putting them on the spot. But it doesn't actually tell you anything. It isn't a data point.