←back to thread

544 points josh2600 | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.237s | source
Show context
meowfly ◴[] No.26717573[source]
The comment from the article echos my own sentiments:

> Speaking solely as a person who is really into encrypted messaging, it terrifies me that they're going to take this really clean story of an encrypted messenger and mix it up with the nightmare of laws and regulations and vulnerability that is cryptocurrency.

Moreover, there are three other points I'd add:

1. I don't like "do everything" apps like WeChat or Line. One of Signals strengths was UX that focused on it's core competency. Early in Signal's development they would add privacy features. Lately they have been adding social features. This, however, feels especially out of left field and likely to hurt the UX.

2. This smells like dev resources will be spent building and maintaining something not related to messaging.

3. I've always had a "don't let perfect be the enemy of good" rationalization that gives Signal autonomy to grow a privacy centric messaging app despite the deficits (e.g lack of federation). In contrast, I personally associate "crypto" with "scam". There have been so many shady ICOs and pump-dump schemes around crypto. This will taint the product for those of us who don't think of crypto currency as being anything more than pump-and-dump schemes and a way to buy dab rigs online.

replies(16): >>26717639 #>>26717735 #>>26717739 #>>26717937 #>>26719072 #>>26719095 #>>26719299 #>>26719963 #>>26720322 #>>26720564 #>>26720761 #>>26720886 #>>26721182 #>>26721555 #>>26721814 #>>26726903 #
TriNetra ◴[] No.26720886[source]
I don't know how will it play out for Signal in countries which have banned or are planning to ban crypto as a currency. RBI had issued policy to banks to stop providing banking services to people/organizations holding/trading in crypto. Though the blanket ban was invalidated by the supreme court after two years, but using it as currency is against Indian Law and the government is working on a new law to further restrict it (read legalizing RBI policy to a great extent as I understood) .

In such cases, Signal could easily be banned in such countries outright.

replies(2): >>26721169 #>>26722380 #
1. ironMonkey ◴[] No.26722380[source]
Nothing really stops Signal from shipping a build w/o a crypto wallet to comply.