←back to thread

544 points josh2600 | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
RL_Quine ◴[] No.26714582[source]
This is garbage, and shouldn't be part of Signal.

Everything on the internet is being corrupted with adding cryptocurrency scams where they absolutely don't belong, it turns Signal from an obvious recommendation into something that makes me hesitate. There's something to be said for focusing on doing one thing well, and that doesn't mean turning a communication platform into a kitchen sink.

replies(7): >>26714678 #>>26714732 #>>26714836 #>>26714899 #>>26715286 #>>26715768 #>>26716324 #
ncmncm ◴[] No.26715286[source]
Agree. It would be OK to make Signal able to integrate payment systems and make this thing compatible with that or with any other comm that implements the interface. Tying them together is pernicious.

Anyway Signal is itself pernicious by being tied to a phone number and to Google Play services, and by being very choosy about who gets ports.

I had high hopes for Matrix, once they got E2EE, but they have flubbed that by requiring a very heavyweight bounce server that won't fit on (e.g.) your typical home router or super-cheap cloud VM. Matrix should enable a place to keep your message archive independent of the bounce server, and allow gatewaying a non-public storage service via the lightweight bounce service.

But Element.io's business model is tied to heavy-weight bounce service.

replies(5): >>26715441 #>>26715481 #>>26716569 #>>26717503 #>>26717644 #
1. miloignis ◴[] No.26716569[source]
Just as a quick note, I run Synapse (the heavyweight server, not Dendrite the light-weight one!) for myself and a few friends on a modest 1GB of RAM VPS with a few bridges and have no problems. Looking forward to Dendrite getting feature-parity and swapping over to be even lighter.