←back to thread

425 points nixass | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.21s | source
1. ncmncm ◴[] No.26679499[source]
The ITER project has no plans ever to boil so much as one gallon of water for public power. It is 100% a "research project", yet not even planned to try out until 2050. Then, maybe start a production plant after they finish experimenting, maybe in time for 2100 if everything works out perfectly. Which it won't.

If $10B is hard (i.e. impossible) to justify for proven fission, how about $100B for fusion? $200B?

Nobody involved expects ever? to field a competitive Tokamak power station. Not in their lifetime, not in their grandchildrens' lifetime. That is not the purpose of the project.

It has a different purpose. Its main purpose is to provide employment for hot-neutron physicists, to maintain a population to be available to draw on for sporadic weapons work. Another purpose it shares with a lot of others, to provide a reliable long-term conduit of public funds to select private hands. The hot-neutron physicists are not getting those $billions, but somebody is.

Every penny spent on ITER is stolen from other possibly viable projects. Imagine how many GW-years could be generated by 2050 by solar and wind paid for out of what is earmarked for ITER.