←back to thread

425 points nixass | 4 comments | | HN request time: 1.744s | source
Show context
philipkglass ◴[] No.26674051[source]
I hope that the federal government can provide incentives to keep reactors running that would otherwise close prematurely.

5.1 gigawatts of American reactors are expected to retire this year: https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=46436

It's a shame that the US is retiring working reactors while still burning fossil fuels for electricity. Reactors are far safer and cleaner than fossil electric generation. It's mostly the low price of natural gas that is driving these early retirements. Low gas prices have also retired a lot of coal usage -- which is good! -- but we'd make more climate progress if those low prices didn't also threaten nuclear generation.

Some states like New York already provided incentives to keep reactors running for climate reasons:

https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=41534

Federal policy could be more comprehensive.

replies(6): >>26674195 #>>26675068 #>>26675523 #>>26675557 #>>26679016 #>>26681646 #
antattack ◴[] No.26675557[source]
About Iowas Duane Arnold plant that is being closed:

"The Mark I containment was undersized in the original design; the Nuclear Regulatory Commission's Harold Denton estimated a 90% probability of explosive failure if the pressure containment system were ever needed in a severe accident.[18] This design flaw may have been the reason that the tsunami in 2011 led to explosions and fire in Fukushima Daiichi nuclear disaster.[19]" (Wikipedia)

It's likely that many old power plants are just not safe and too costly to operate reliably.

replies(2): >>26675648 #>>26675701 #
1. effie ◴[] No.26675701[source]
Yes but their safety could be improved, new containment system can be built etc. Governments should step up and change the incentives to keep the good plants in operation. Being unprofitable is not a good reason to decommission a nuclear plant.

> DAEC's operation helps avoid the emission of nearly 4 million tons of carbon dioxide annually, which is the equivalent of taking almost 800,000 cars off the road

replies(2): >>26675817 #>>26678343 #
2. ThinkBeat ◴[] No.26675817[source]
There are a lot of advantages to designing a better nuclear plant to be built than to retrofit one that is designed wrong from the beginning
replies(1): >>26676096 #
3. Lammy ◴[] No.26676096[source]
Are retrofits and new construction equally possible in today's regulatory and media environments?
replies(1): >>26678455 #
4. dundercoder ◴[] No.26678455{3}[source]
The NRC and DOE levy so much regulation, I really can’t imagine how anyone can make a profit with any changes.