Most active commenters
  • jfk13(3)
  • gspr(3)

←back to thread

224 points gurjeet | 11 comments | | HN request time: 0.752s | source | bottom
1. jfk13 ◴[] No.26634076[source]
I don't know where this is pulling data from, but:

> Country United Kingdom

> Country (ISO code) GB

> In EU? true

Well, that's inaccurate for a start.

replies(3): >>26634142 #>>26634202 #>>26634560 #
2. Jonnax ◴[] No.26634142[source]
I presume the reason is GDPR checking.

Has the UK data protection law deviated significantly from GDPR?

replies(2): >>26634250 #>>26634565 #
3. kuroguro ◴[] No.26634202[source]
> I don't know where this is pulling data from

Free version of MaxMind's GeoIP - a lot of services use them but the free version is the most inaccurate. That being said, not sure it's a mistake on the EU thing?

replies(1): >>26634259 #
4. jfk13 ◴[] No.26634250[source]
AFAIK data protection law has not (yet, at least) deviated significantly in the UK vs GDPR.

But if that's the reason, it should be labelled as such: "GDPR applies" or something.

5. jfk13 ◴[] No.26634259[source]
The UK has unquestionably left the EU.
replies(2): >>26634318 #>>26640849 #
6. kuroguro ◴[] No.26634318{3}[source]
Thought the underlying API may mean something else more generic, but no - just running an outdated version https://dev.maxmind.com/release-note/united-kingdom-will-no-...

The free DB has to be re-downloaded monthly IIRC.

7. gspr ◴[] No.26634560[source]
Presuming that the "in-EU" is actually meant to refer to "subject to most EU legislation, and in particular the GDPR", then it's incorrect in the opposite way for Norway: it shows false.
8. gspr ◴[] No.26634565[source]
If that is the case, then it's incorrectly showing false for Norway, who as an EEA member is subject to the GDPR.
replies(1): >>26634643 #
9. drdec ◴[] No.26634643{3}[source]
It is a GitHub project, there's already an issue for the UK:

https://github.com/mpolden/echoip/issues/130

Perhaps you ought to open one for Norway? (I don't think it would be appropriate for me to do it because I am not seeing the issue, not being in Norway.)

replies(1): >>26637271 #
10. gspr ◴[] No.26637271{4}[source]
Done, thanks
11. PhillyG ◴[] No.26640849{3}[source]
Still uses GDPR though, so perhaps the label really refers to using EU data law save and they've not updated it to reflect this technicality.