←back to thread

292 points kaboro | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.298s | source
Show context
sarosh ◴[] No.25058471[source]
I thought this statement from the article had more than a hint of truth to it: "Figma in Electron may destroy your battery, but that destruction will take twice as long, if not more, with an A-series chip inside!"
replies(2): >>25058689 #>>25059788 #
lalo2302 ◴[] No.25058689[source]
This will allow Sketch to kick Figma's ass as soon as they solve their online multi-user editing
replies(9): >>25058736 #>>25058797 #>>25058953 #>>25059139 #>>25059245 #>>25059600 #>>25060072 #>>25060320 #>>25063320 #
lekevicius ◴[] No.25060072[source]
UI designer here, migrated from Sketch (used for about 5 years) to Figma. I'm happy to celebrate Sketch as a great Mac app, and I still keep it in the dock for short tasks, but I'm not looking back. Figma won me over.

And it's not just Figma's collaborative features. Figma made fundamentally better decisions about design tool feature set. Better vector editor. Better concept of "symbol" as a component. Much better approach to auto-layout. Much better approach to shared colors / text styles.

At every step, Figma is just a better designed design tool. And a large part of why it's taking the design world by storm is exactly that. Most design work is done alone, not collaboratively dragging elements on the screen. Figma is just a great tool. Sketch is trying to catch up, but they would need to modify a LOT of their past decisions to get to the spot Figma is at.

replies(1): >>25061368 #
nbzso ◴[] No.25061368[source]
I am reading all this Figma talk in utter disbelief. Actually in my view Sketch never had a chance to replace Illustrator or Affinity Designer. Figma? For collaboration if use case is demanding it may be. But suddenly UI design field is filled with decorators doing boxes with drop shadow but having "Designer"opinions. May be I am in mostly silent minority of professionals that don't search and prize tools over essential skills. As a designer your work must be detached of workflow sentiments. Tools are tools. Nothing more. I can make a great UI with Inkscape any day I want. I can implement and test it in pure HTML/CSS prototype. So what? On Apple and cloud computing in general. I like owning things, call me old-fashioned, boomer, or whatever. When I own a piece of software, I can use it without someone logging my mouse and keyboard, without fear of losing internet connection. Is this a small thing to behold?
replies(2): >>25062352 #>>25062866 #
1. specialist ◴[] No.25062866[source]
I used to be a CADD jockey. Taught 100s of people. Did a lot of 3rd party tooling.

CADD is a 800lb angry gorilla sitting between you and your design.

Yes, it's a poor craftsperson who blames their tools. And, sometimes it's nice when the tool doesn't fight you every step of the journey.

I imagine the same is true for graphic design.