←back to thread

292 points kaboro | 2 comments | | HN request time: 0.448s | source
1. leoc ◴[] No.25059030[source]
> notably Apple avoided the trap of integrating hardware (the iPod) with hardware (the Mac), which would have handicapped the former to prop up the latter. Instead the company took advantage of the flexibility of software to port iTunes to Windows

That's how things turned out, but not how they were originally meant to be. Jobs' reluctance to port iTunes to Windows was so obvious that even the Isaacson bio made it clear. And it wasn't simply an atavistic impulse, it was faithfulness to his "Digital Hub" strategy which saw smart-device integration as a way to sell Macintoshes. Jobs was a late and reluctant convert to the idea of a post-PC era. Repasting an earlier comment of mine https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9470925 :

>> If you look at Apple's trajectory over the last 15 years, you can see the vision was consistently outlined from the very beginning—the Digital Hub strategy ([link working in 2020: https://youtu.be/AnrM4n6S3CU?t=2585 ]).

> That's not really the case though. As Jobs outlined it in that video, the Digital Hub strategy was to sell Macintoshes by positioning them as something you could dock your consumer-electronics gadgets, mostly from third parties, into. It was a plan to sell hubs, not spokes. This strategy had limited viability for Apple, because a typical consumer wasn't likely to think "I've just bought this $500 camcorder, so now I need to spend twice that or more on a Mac in order to offload and edit the video". If they were going to use any computer as the digital hub for their camcorder, it was probably going to be their Windows PC. That's probably why iTunes for Windows was such a difficult and long-drawn-out decision for Jobs: because it was a decision to mostly abandon the Digital Hub approach in favour of selling more of the spokes. Then Apple's slow and initially reluctant embrace of the "post-PC era" with over-the-air iDevice updates and cloud storage to partly displace iTunes means that it's increasingly taking nearly the opposite of Jobs' 2001 stance: "We're clearly migrating away from the PC as the centrepiece" and "We don't think of it in terms of the PC business anymore" are things that Tim Cook could say today without really startling anyone.

At his 2007 joint interview with Gates at D5 https://www.wsj.com/video/bill-gates-and-steve-jobs-at-d5-fu... Jobs is coming round to the post-PC agenda, reluctantly.

replies(1): >>25059135 #
2. ghaff ◴[] No.25059135[source]
Mobile and device proliferation more broadly snuck up on a lot of people. (Including me. I wrote a piece in 2003 about Apple morphing into an entertainment company and it was way too living room-centric. http://bitmasons.com.s3-website-us-east-1.amazonaws.com/pubs...)

The general view in the 1990s into the early 2000s was that you would have a centralized home computer/storage hub/etc. that everything else connected to.