←back to thread

1183 points robenkleene | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.241s | source
Show context
_qulr ◴[] No.24844030[source]
"You have to trust Apple", it's said. But I suspect that if you actually knew how much your Apple devices were phoning home to Cupertino, you wouldn't trust Apple anymore. Using Little Snitch (the kernel extension) was a real eye opener for me. Especially when I allowed Little Snitch to block all Apple processes (by disabling the built-in iCloud Services and macOS Services rule groups).

This may be a good time to remind folks of my blog post where I explain how Catalina phones home when you run unsigned executables, including shell scripts! In the article I mentioned that you can prevent this with Little Snitch. But that was the LS kext. Is it even possible anymore? https://lapcatsoftware.com/articles/catalina-executables.htm...

Let me just quote one comment from the HN discussion of that article: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23278253 "Making this about speed is burying the lede. From a privacy and user-freedom perspective, it's horrifying. Don't think so? Apple now theoretically has a centralized database of every Mac user who's ever used youtube-dl. Or Tor. Or TrueCrypt."

It's all too easy to dismiss the privacy violations that we're not aware of. Out of sight, out of mind.

replies(2): >>24844381 #>>24845966 #
jachee ◴[] No.24844381[source]
Apply Occam's Razor.

Why would the most successful company in history—a success gained in no small part through protecting users, selling hardware and services instead of their data, and promoting and enhancing privacy as a first-class feature—do that sort of thing? What possible benefit could such a centralized database serve? How's that gonna make them more money?

replies(2): >>24844454 #>>24846051 #
1. _qulr ◴[] No.24844454[source]
I'd love to apply Occam's Razor to Apple's network connections. Those entitles should not be multiplied without necessity. That's why I use Little Snitch!

Seriously though, Tim Cook has been absolutely trashing Apple's hard won reputation by relentlessly pushing (via push notifications no less) TV shows and other garbage "subscriptions" on computer buyers. It's not what I signed up for when I became a Mac user many years ago.