←back to thread

113 points blinding-streak | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0.265s | source
Show context
jeffbee ◴[] No.24110022[source]
Apple exempts all their iOS software from their own privacy scaremongering. iOS never pops up a scary dialog warning you that Camera has accessed your location twice in the last week, even though Camera accesses your location every time you start it. There is a completely separate iOS privacy regime for Apple's own apps.
replies(10): >>24110218 #>>24110222 #>>24110240 #>>24110241 #>>24110424 #>>24110468 #>>24110686 #>>24110765 #>>24110829 #>>24112373 #
3pt14159 ◴[] No.24110218[source]
The idea is that we trust Apple already by using their computers. If Apple was sending that data back to their servers each time then that would ruin their reputation, but there are no such guarantees for third-party applications. Yes, theoretically, Apple reviews third party code, but it is easy enough to slip something small by them.
replies(2): >>24110328 #>>24110361 #
slowmovintarget ◴[] No.24110361[source]
We are not using "their computers". We are using our own computers. Apple made them.

I realize Apple likely doesn't feel the same way. I also think this is kind of an "of course Apple does that." A great many people pay money for this particular experience.

replies(1): >>24110832 #
chipotle_coyote ◴[] No.24110832[source]
With due respect, you're giving the OP a deliberately ungenerous reading to score a point. If I tell you "I like using Dell's servers because [reasons]" you wouldn't say, "They're YOUR servers, Dell just made them" because I said "Dell's servers" rather than "Dell servers".
replies(2): >>24111774 #>>24112126 #
1. slowmovintarget ◴[] No.24111774[source]
The trouble is with the language though, especially when thinking about who is permitted to do what with the device.

I wasn't trying to score cheap points, I was attempting to demonstrate two concepts that had been collapsed into the pronoun "their" really must be considered separately when thinking about authorization.

I apologize if the message was muddled in "gotcha" language. I aim to do better than that.