←back to thread

428 points coronadisaster | 3 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
philistine ◴[] No.23677180[source]
I’ve heard so many people complain on HN about Safari’s lack of support for APIs. Before now, we didn’t have a public justification why Apple refused to implement them. Now we know.

The price of a Safari user in the ad market is going down, and it’s exactly what should be happening. I’m very happy with Apple.

https://9to5mac.com/2019/12/09/apple-safari-privacy-feature-...

replies(8): >>23677237 #>>23677240 #>>23677307 #>>23677333 #>>23677632 #>>23678116 #>>23681749 #>>23682896 #
fastball ◴[] No.23677307[source]
Except "privacy" as a justification is BS.

You can implement these APIs while at the same time requiring explicit permission from the user before a web application can use them. This preserves privacy while also giving users the option to have much more powerful web applications.

Apple doesn't want to implement these APIs because currently if you want access to these things on iOS, you need to go through their walled garden App Store, where they get a big chunk of any revenue you might make on such a service and can nerf competitors and all the other anti-competitive stuff they're doing.

replies(7): >>23677413 #>>23677496 #>>23677509 #>>23677610 #>>23679646 #>>23679893 #>>23680797 #
user5994461 ◴[] No.23677413[source]
I don't want random web sites I open (and their ads) to ask permission to scan bluetooth in my area and use usb devices connected to my computer. A website has no business doing any of that. There is no justification for these API to exist.
replies(5): >>23677428 #>>23677459 #>>23677466 #>>23677539 #>>23679532 #
1. halostatue ◴[] No.23679532[source]
I’m tired of websites asking if I want to enable push notifications from them. The answer is, and will always be, GTFO.
replies(1): >>23679717 #
2. Hedja ◴[] No.23679717[source]
In most browsers, you can go into settings and default it to block without asking.
replies(1): >>23680519 #
3. joking ◴[] No.23680519[source]
most sites use a html modal to ask for the permission, and if you answer yes they make the request to the browser api which shows his own modal.