←back to thread

677 points saeedjabbar | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
dang ◴[] No.23543783[source]
This is an interesting and in-depth article that was inappropriately flagged. I've turned off the flags.

I understand the impulse to flag follow-up stories [1], especially on the hottest controversies of the moment, which always produce a flood of articles, most of which aren't very good. Curiosity and repetition don't go together [2]. But it's important to recognize the articles that are higher than median quality and not simply flag an entire category mechanically. Curiosity isn't mechanical either.

[1] https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

[2] https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...

[3] https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...

replies(5): >>23543916 #>>23543987 #>>23544124 #>>23544566 #>>23545855 #
luckylion ◴[] No.23543916[source]
> This is an interesting and in-depth article that was inappropriately flagged. I've switched off the flags.

Consider that people are not flagging it because "it's a follow up article", but because a) it's Bloomberg, ergo hard to believe b) it's the seven billionth "minorities in tech" story in the past month c) it's not going to create an interesting comment section d) they don't find it as interesting as you do.

It's your site of course, but if "moderators build the front page" is the new modus operandi, I'll be disappointed.

replies(6): >>23543970 #>>23543973 #>>23543983 #>>23544002 #>>23544048 #>>23544161 #
wbronitsky ◴[] No.23544002[source]
> b) it's the seven billionth "minorities in tech" story in the past month

I would urge people to stop and question that if they are tired of the "billion"s of stories about BIPOC, what must BIPOC be feeling about their systemic erasure from many facets of our society, including journalism and entrepreneurship. This article allows us to think about and discuss those issues.

The article is not hard to believe, is one of substance that I find interesting, and the content of the comment section is not the only arbiter of what should go on Hacker News.

I would suggest that Occam's Razor is a better tool here; a small number of people who want to silence the idea the article presents are trying to silence it.

replies(2): >>23544052 #>>23544055 #
olivermarks ◴[] No.23544055[source]
What's BIPOC?
replies(3): >>23544105 #>>23544119 #>>23544284 #
olivermarks[dead post] ◴[] No.23544105[source]
I looked it up - according to the NYT 'black, indigenous people of color'. Based on this shouldn't the correct wording for 'black lives matter' be 'BIPOC lives matter'? Surely people of color and indigenous people are taking offense at this?
oh_sigh ◴[] No.23544181[source]
It also somehow places black and indigenous people as not "people of color"(I assume they aren't counting white indigenous people like the Sami).
replies(3): >>23544233 #>>23544374 #>>23544602 #
jt0 ◴[] No.23544602[source]
This is an incorrect reading of the term. BIPOC is US-specific. You'd have to look at teachings from Sami activists to see the most useful framing for indigenous erasure in Scandinavia. Also, it does not place black and indigenous people as not POC, the aim is "undoing Native invisibility, anti-Blackness, dismantling white supremacy and advancing racial justice."[0]. It instead centers the two groups who have been the most marginalized in the US.

[0] https://www.thebipocproject.org/

replies(1): >>23546921 #
1. oh_sigh ◴[] No.23546921[source]
Limiting yourself to two seems too stringent when it is just a letter in an acronym. There has been huge anti Chinese and anti Japanese sentiment in the US. I may start thebijpoccproject.com to address the invisibility of Asians in the mind of US anti racism advocates.