←back to thread

1525 points garyclarke27 | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
ipsum2 ◴[] No.23219562[source]
My favorite (and only) podcasting app. I hope someone who works at Google reads this and flag it internally.

This quote really sums up how ridiculous Google is being:

> What Google is asking of Podcast Addict would be comparable to Google asking a web browser app to remove references to all the websites and social media posts that reference the coronavirus unless the reference comes from an official government entity or public health organization.

replies(9): >>23219675 #>>23220287 #>>23220589 #>>23220888 #>>23221059 #>>23221381 #>>23222497 #>>23232236 #>>23232657 #
Crosseye_Jack ◴[] No.23219675[source]
> asking a web browser app to remove references to all the websites and social media posts

Except usually a web browser doesn't include a index of sites, You go to a another site (Google/Bing) for that. If a browser does include "recommended sites" the landing pages of those sites best keep to Google's and Apples rules. For an extreme example, If Firefox was promoting PornHub on the new tab page we could understand why Google or Apple would tell them to cut it out, but it doesn't stop you from visiting the site.

I'm not saying I agree with what Google have done here (IMO they should re-instate Podcast Addict), Just that I can see why Google could think "recommended podcasts" and podcast indexes come under the "included content" of an app.

EDIT: As others has said here, It's more like Google banning YouTube because it contains video's about covid 19 which don't come from "approved sources" (Though Google did demonetize people for talking about it and de-rank non "approved sources")

replies(8): >>23219715 #>>23219757 #>>23219776 #>>23219788 #>>23220019 #>>23221092 #>>23222194 #>>23232276 #
robkop ◴[] No.23219715[source]
I would disagree in saying it's like Google banning YouTube as YouTube both hosts the actual data as well as filters the data that gets put onto the platform.
replies(1): >>23219742 #
1. Crosseye_Jack ◴[] No.23219742{3}[source]
Yeah podcast app's rarely host the content themselves (though some do mirror the files to their own CDN's and Spotify have recently started doing exclusive podcasts).

It was more that Podcast app's come with a curated list of podcasts and a search feature backed into the application then the actual hosting of the content.