←back to thread

376 points undefined1 | 1 comments | | HN request time: 0s | source
Show context
danielscrubs ◴[] No.22975715[source]
Can someone explain to me why affirmative action is necessary? Why not just send in your GPA and let a computer check which school you can go to based on your preference? Why resort to low-key racism?

Low-income junior high-schools of course needs more money from the government than the high-income schools to combat equality issues. Because let's face it, it's the low-income people that struggle and always will, money IS power.

replies(3): >>22975744 #>>22975898 #>>22975936 #
balls187 ◴[] No.22975898[source]
> Why not just send in your GPA and let a computer check which school you can go to based on your preference? Why resort to low-key racism?

College admissions were based that way. And it disproportionately benefited white students, and affirmative action policies were implemented to combat that.

Think of Affirmative Action similar to weighted GPA's.

College Admissions attempted to take a population and normalize them to a pair of datapoints (GPA/SAT/ACT). Affirmative action policies attempted to weigh lower scores higher, factoring in historical biases.

A (white) friend explained it like this: Think of playing a game of monopoly and if you're white you start with 2x the money, and given 1/4 of the properties on the board. If you're black, you start with 1/2 the money, and the all prices are doubled. How likely is it for a black person to win?

replies(2): >>22976035 #>>22976233 #
danielscrubs ◴[] No.22976233[source]
So based on skincolor you can tell if I started with 2x the money? You can tell whether he is a millionaire or not? If he lived in a safe area or not? You judge someone based on skincolor, you can back it up with numbers sure, but you didn't judge based on who he is.

Telling people that if only they had a different skincolor that maybe they would have made it. Making the focus on something you cant change is just poison.

If you fix the economic divide violence goes down, substance abuse go down, happiness goes up, and the major beneficiaries are minorities and the ones that will be hit the hardest are the majority group, no racism necessary.

replies(2): >>22976349 #>>22978387 #
1. MiroF ◴[] No.22978387{3}[source]
> You judge someone based on skincolor, you can back it up with numbers sure, but you didn't judge based on who he is.

The problem is that other people, way way way earlier in the educational pipeline, are already making these judgements, but the opposite of Harvard.

"Oh no, Andre, I'm not sure that you would actually want to take this honors science course that much, how about I just put you on on-level?"

This happens all the time, not to mention intergenerational effects.